Do Short Runs Really Need a Hydration Vest? Josh Kerr Starts a Debate

| 5 min read

My one and only outing in a hydration vest ended with two bottles slapping against my ribs and water trickling down my shirt. I spent more time adjusting the thing than enjoying the run. So when Josh Kerr suggested that recreational runners might be overequipping themselves, I was inclined to nod along.

Kerr made the comment during a Reddit AMA hosted by BBC Sport. The Scottish middle-distance star, who broke the mile world record in July with a 3:42.66 finish, was asked about the growing popularity of running vests. His answer was blunt: "I'd say that if you're running less than 12 miles, you probably don't need to bring water bottles with you." He added that runners in cities can usually stop at a store if they need something to drink.

Two athletes embrace joyfully after a race, with other runners in the background.

Courtesy Brooks. Josh Kerr celebrates his mile world record at the London Diamond League in July 2026.

Why his point isn't as outlandish as it sounds

Consider the source. Kerr is a world-record holder, an Olympic medalist, and a 1500-meter world champion. He knows a thing or two about logging miles. Twelve miles might look different on his watch than on mine, but I don't think the suggestion was outrageous. For a short run in a city with plenty of access to water, carrying liquid is often a habit more than a need.

Plenty of people disagree, of course. That's the internet.

The safety argument that changed the conversation

Runner Natalie (@natalie.the.capn) shared Kerr's comments on Threads with a pointed response. She wears a hydration belt on every outing so she has somewhere to keep her phone, particularly in case of an emergency. "Funny how men rarely think of that," she wrote.

That's a fair hit. I'm a guy, and I don't face the same safety considerations many women do when running alone. I carry my phone in my hand because phones keep getting bigger and the pockets in my running shorts haven't kept up. Her point reframes the gear question. For some runners, a belt or vest isn't about hydration at all. It's about carrying the thing that gets help to them if something goes wrong.

She also noted that some of her routes stretch six miles or more between places to get water. That's a different problem from the one I face on my home loops, and it's one Kerr's city-centric comment doesn't really address.

Where I land on the gear question

I live in New York City. Central Park has water fountains (that work most of the time), and there's usually a deli within walking distance where I can grab a Gatorade. From that vantage point, I can see why Kerr's approach makes sense for shorter runs. I've also tried handheld bottles and waist straps, and neither has earned a permanent place in my routine. Between the bouncing, the adjusting, and the occasional hand cramp, I'd rather carry as little as possible.

That changes during marathon training, which I've now put myself through four times. The long runs are when water matters, mostly because I'm trying to wash down gels that taste like wet cardboard. Stopping to buy something, pausing my watch, and breaking stride halfway through a long run kills the rhythm. Carrying water on those days isn't gear creep. It's part of the workout.

The Threads debate has also pulled in other perspectives. One commenter, siding with Kerr, wrote, "Yeah im gonna listen to the guy who runs for a living but thanks." Others pointed out that beginners, slower runners, and people training in hot weather can have very different hydration needs. They're right. Twelve miles is a long way for plenty of runners, and access to water, weather, pace, and personal circumstances all change the math. Kerr himself acknowledged that people carry gear for different reasons. That nuance got lost as the quote bounced around social media.

Still, I think he has a fair point about how much equipment we talk ourselves into needing. Many runners default to carrying water because it feels responsible, not because a specific run demands it. If your vest makes you more comfortable or gives you peace of mind, wear it. For my own runs, I'll keep my phone close and bring water when the distance or the heat calls for it. The better question isn't whether 12 miles requires a bottle. It's whether the gear solves a problem you actually have on the route you actually run.

Source: Thomas Smith · www.runnersworld.com