How Higher Weekly Mileage Helped Me Finish the New York City Marathon Stronger
Running the New York City Marathon in exactly 4:09:48 two years in a row sounds like a statistical joke. But the matching clock times hide the useful part of the story: this year, I ran the later miles faster, and they felt easier. The change that mattered most was a bigger weekly mileage load. That’s more significant than the identical finish times make it look.
It was my seventh time running through the five boroughs, and the race turned up a few lessons. My splits were different even though the result wasn’t. Here’s how I built more mileage into training, managed the added load, and reached my strongest marathon finish yet, without setting a personal record. (New York City Marathon results)
How I increased my weekly mileage
For the London Marathon in April, and for New York and Sydney the year before, I trained with an AI training app. I set it to three running days a week so I could keep strength training two or three days a week. Living in New York also means plenty of walking: roughly four to five miles each day, on top of running.
While reporting a series for Runner’s World on durability, I began paying closer attention to weekly mileage. I’d topped out around 30 to 35 miles a week for each of those three marathons. That gave me room to build, but the question was how much more I could handle without raising my injury risk.
I asked Andrew Kastor, head coach of the Asics Mammoth Track Club, to review the plan I intended to follow: Runner’s World’s Break Four Hours. I also planned to strength train twice a week. The plan peaks at 48 miles across at least four running days. That’s not a huge total by the standards of very high-mileage training, but it was a marked jump for me.
“Between 32 and 50 is night and day,” Kastor said. “You’re going to notice a big difference in your staying power after mile 20.”
That increase made sense because I’d built a solid base before starting the 16-week plan, and felt ready when week one arrived. The plan also gives mileage ranges instead of fixed targets, which let me adjust the workload. Kastor uses that approach with athletes because it eases the pressure: on a fatigue-heavy day, you can choose the lower end.
He also recommended taking the optional run of up to three miles every other week—the sessions marked zero to three miles. The payoff, he said, could come late in the race, when I might still be able to hold a 9:07 or nine-minute mile pace.
How I managed the extra training
More miles only help if you recover from them. Kastor told me to watch for overtraining symptoms, including a higher resting heart rate, lower heart rate variability, persistent fatigue, or workouts where I felt unusually flat. If my legs weren’t recovering from week to week, he advised cutting mileage and taking two days off to let them heal.
I felt good throughout the build, which I partly credit to a change in strength training made with my physical therapist. I lifted heavier weights with less total volume and added isometric exercises for tendon health. I also started looking forward to running days more than rest days, probably because running had become a more regular part of my week.
Kastor stressed that mileage depends on recovery and nutrition. “In order to do more mileage, you have to sleep well and eat well,” he said. I paid particular attention to carbohydrates. I’d been prioritizing protein and had realized I was falling short on carbs. Sleep was already a priority, so I kept aiming for eight to nine hours a night.
On Kastor’s advice, I booked a sports massage every other week. After long runs—and sometimes in the evening on other days—I also used the Therabody JetBoots PRO Plus. I find they help me relax before bed.
Shoes can play a role, too. Kastor said cushioning may help runners tolerate more volume because their bodies take less of a beating. I trained in the Asics Gel-Nimbus 28, a highly cushioned shoe that Runner’s World reviewers describe as having a premium, long-lasting ride. It gave me energy return and support as the miles added up. That doesn’t establish that the shoes caused my stronger finish; the mileage, strength work, fueling, and recovery all changed alongside them.

How mileage boosts durability
The clearest payoff from adding mileage wasn’t a personal record. It was how much stronger I felt late in the race—and that’s a meaningful result, even if the finish time didn’t show it.
There’s a good reason higher volume can help. Experts I spoke with about durability pointed to weekly mileage as a major contributor to holding up late in a marathon. Research links longer runs of at least 90 minutes and greater overall training volume with improved durability, while other research suggests that more mileage—particularly easy running—can support faster marathon times.
“We start where the athlete is with their fitness and then we progress upward because volume is king,” says Kastor. “More is better as long as you stay healthy.” That caveat matters: building mileage only helps if your body can absorb it.
Kastor also thinks frequent running trains the nervous system to make movement more efficient. He points to his wife, Olympic marathon bronze medalist Deena Kastor, who at one point ran more than 140 miles across 13 runs a week. He remembers her waking from a nap, still groggy, putting on her shoes, and heading out. The point, he says, is the accumulated practice: “If you [run] over and over and over and over again, then you get really, really good at it.” He believes that repetition can sharpen the nervous system’s role in the efficiency of running mechanics.
How the Volume Increase Paid Off
I didn’t set a PR after increasing my mileage. But the last four miles tell a different story:
2025:
- Mile 23: 9:41
- Mile 24: 10:00
- Mile 25: 9:50
- Mile 26: 9:51
2026:
- Mile 23: 9:23
- Mile 24: 9:38
- Mile 25: 9:18
- Mile 26: 9:02
The numbers show a clear difference, and I felt it. In 2025, I was surprised I could hold the paces I did; I remember finishing exhausted. This year, I’d held back because I was worried about fading, yet I felt as if I were cruising down 59th Street toward mile 25. Later, I had enough energy to walk almost a mile to dinner and back home.
That late-race strength exposed the bigger limiter: my confidence. I’d run 8:47 miles at miles 4 and 5, then slowed because I feared I couldn’t sustain the effort. By the finish, I knew the race had been more of a mental test than a physical one. Next time, I’ll need to trust the fitness I’ve built and commit to a faster pace earlier.
I’d focused on the training plan and nutrition, but hadn’t prepared for how intimidating race pace might feel. Most of my long runs were much easier than race pace, apart from a handful with tempo miles in the middle. So the idea of running 26 miles at a 9:00 pace unsettled me. Now I believe I can do it. More mileage helped build that belief—and the strength to back it up.