Colin Cowherd Puts Bears First After Seahawks’ Loss to Chicago
Chicago’s 34-17 win over Seattle did more than knock the defending champion Seahawks to 4-4. It moved the Bears to the top of Colin Cowherd’s Week 8 Herd Hierarchy, giving his earlier prediction of a Chicago-Seattle NFC title game a sharper edge. Cowherd now sees Chicago as the best team in football, while Seattle’s loss leaves it in his top four but exposes how much can go wrong when its offensive line is depleted.
The rankings reveal a league with no shortage of capable teams—and few without a qualifying concern. Kansas City has penalties and a shaky kicking game to fix. Buffalo keeps giving the ball away. Denver keeps winning close games despite being outgained. Cowherd’s take is less a clean separation between contenders and pretenders than a test of which teams can correct their flaws before those flaws decide a bigger game.
Chicago’s defense changes the conversation
The Bears’ case rests in part on a defense that pressured Seattle quarterback Sam Darnold 12 times and brought him down three times. Cowherd said Chicago “should have” had six sacks, a point that underlines how disruptive the front looked even without turning every pressure into a finish.
Chicago’s defensive plan also caught his attention. The team recorded that pressure while using its lowest blitz rate of the season. That gives the Bears a way to unsettle quarterbacks without regularly sending extra rushers, which can leave more defenders available in coverage.
There’s help expected on the way. Cowherd said the Bears’ “high-priced safety” is due back in December and corner Malik Muhammad is expected to return in a couple of weeks. He sees those additions strengthening positions that had been viewed as weaknesses. If the defense keeps generating pressure with a restrained blitz, better health in the secondary could make it harder for opponents to find easy answers.
That’s a persuasive profile after a statement win, though one result doesn’t settle the season. The larger question is whether Chicago can sustain the pressure and tighten its coverage as opponents adjust. Cowherd’s top ranking says he believes the Bears have the personnel and coaching to do it.
Seattle’s loss came with a major offensive line problem
Cowherd didn’t treat Monday night as proof that Seattle has fallen out of the contender conversation. He still considers the Seahawks a top-four team, pointing to their talent and coaching. But the conditions around the loss matter: Seattle was without its left tackle, left guard and right guard, forcing it to shuffle the offensive line against a Chicago front featuring Jeffery Simmons and Montez Sweat.
“That’s not going to work” against pass rushers Cowherd describes as game wreckers. The Seahawks were also playing their third straight game in prime time, and their running back was returning from injury. Those factors give Seattle some context for the 34-17 defeat, but they don’t erase the need for better depth and stability up front.
Seattle could use another receiver, too, in Cowherd’s view. That concern echoes his assessment of Kansas City: both teams have strong rosters, but he’d like to see another reliable option in the passing game. For Seattle, protecting the quarterback and finding more receiving help are distinct problems, and the offensive line disruptions made the first one especially visible against Chicago.
Kansas City and Buffalo are making avoidable mistakes
The Chiefs have lost consecutive games to Seattle and Denver, but Cowherd still expects them to rebound. He sees their next three games as manageable before a short-week trip to Buffalo, and predicts Kansas City will be 8-2 by then. His confidence depends on the team cleaning up details that are already costing it.
Kansas City has the league’s worst penalty differential, according to Cowherd, and he also wants the kicking game to improve. He thinks the team needs a No. 2 wide receiver and would prefer Travis Kelce, 37, not to be the primary target on major plays. The Chiefs have a strong coach and defensive coordinator, he said, and could return to the top five by Thanksgiving if they stop “unraveling” in key areas.
Buffalo’s problem is turnovers. Cowherd puts the Bills just ahead of Kansas City, citing their league-leading scoring offense, but says they’ve committed multiple giveaways in four of their last five games. He also questions the play of their defensive backfield. His baseball comparison is pointed: a team can outplay an opponent and still lose if its “bullpen” fails late. Buffalo’s offensive firepower gives it a high ceiling; giving the ball away threatens to lower it.
Denver’s close-game record resists easy explanation
Denver may be the hardest team for Cowherd to place. The Broncos are 5-0 in one-score games, and he says they’ve won 15 straight games decided by one possession. Yet he also says they’ve been outgained by almost 700 yards and routinely struggle to move the ball in the first half.
Those numbers pull in opposite directions. Cowherd likes the roster, head coach, playmakers and pass rush, and believes quarterback Bo Nix unlocks something late in games. Denver’s record gives that belief some support, but repeated narrow wins leave little margin for the team’s slow starts. Cowherd’s frustration is clear: he likes the people on the roster and still can’t explain the pattern.
Injuries shape the outlook for the rest of the field
Detroit sits at No. 9 in Cowherd’s hierarchy, a position he acknowledges may be too low. The Lions have outgained their opponents in five straight games and have played better defense, but linebacker Jack Campbell is set to miss time. Cowherd calls him a “great player, great human,” and says the injury adds to the pressure on a defense he still doesn’t trust in a big spot. Detroit’s offensive line health matters as well: without time to throw, Jared Goff can become a “sitting duck.”
He sees a strong neutral-field matchup for the Rams against Detroit, especially if Davante Adams is healthy. Cowherd says Los Angeles’ passing offense ranks 26th when Adams doesn’t play, despite having Puka Nacua, multiple tight ends, Matthew Stafford and coach Sean McVay. That reliance is hard to miss. The Rams have the ingredients for a high-powered offense, but need to deliver four strong quarters more consistently.
Jacksonville is No. 7, a ranking Cowherd says may undersell the team. He credits coach Liam Coen and highlights the athleticism of Travis Hunter and Parker Washington, whom he calls two of the NFL’s top five athletes. His reservation is the division: Jacksonville plays the Titans and Colts twice apiece, and he questions how much those matchups reveal about the team’s standing against the league’s strongest opponents.
New England’s case is built around what Drake Maye has done with a depleted group of receivers and tight ends. Cowherd says the Patriots were missing their top three receivers, their No. 2 running back and their top tight end when Maye put the franchise on his shoulders in the second half. He also points to five straight games with multiple touchdown passes. New England’s upcoming games against Green Bay, Detroit and Buffalo will test that momentum, while getting healthy remains a priority.
San Francisco could gain ground as players return. Cowherd expects Nick Bosa, Christian McCaffrey, Mike Evans and Deebo Samuel back, and points to wins over Seattle, Denver and the Rams among the team’s six victories. He credits the 49ers with allowing the fewest big plays, forcing opponents to sustain long drives. The takeaway from Cowherd’s Week 8 rankings is that the race remains open: Chicago has made the strongest recent statement, but health, ball security and protection will determine which teams can keep answering it.