Fernandes backs Carrick after Manchester United’s comeback win over Roma

| 5 min read

Manchester United’s 3-2 comeback against Roma gave Michael Carrick a result he badly needed. Whether it bought him more time is a different question: Bruno Fernandes insists the players weren’t trying to save their manager’s job, and the next test arrives against Aston Villa.

A comeback, and a show of support

United looked in deep trouble after conceding twice in the opening 18 minutes. Supporters responded with boos and protests, including tennis balls thrown onto the pitch. Fernandes’ penalty and two late goals from Matheus Cunha turned the match around and delivered United’s first win in 54 days.

The result came amid doubts about Carrick’s position, which had intensified after a 3-0 defeat to Bournemouth. Fernandes had also been left on the bench for that game, following his public criticism of the tactics after a 4-1 loss to Como four days earlier.

After the Roma match, the captain rejected the idea that the players had rescued Carrick. “We don't need to save anyone's job,” he told Amazon Prime.

Fernandes said the squad had been working to lift itself out of a difficult spell and described reports of a rift between him and Carrick as false. He acknowledged that the manager had dropped him because his performances weren’t at the required level, adding that if the decision was punishment for his comments, “it was right.”

“The manager is the one who makes the decisions,” Fernandes said. “I have to accept them, I have to go forward with that. It doesn't change the belief I have in the manager, in the staff and every player that is in this club.” He said the win “should be” a turning point.

Carrick focuses on the group

Carrick also played down the idea that the result had changed his personal prospects, calling it “a win for us as a football club.” He said the players had shown character under pressure, and that the run of adversity had revealed more about the group to both him and the squad.

That public show of support matters, but it doesn’t settle the question of Carrick’s future. A comeback can shift the mood around a team without changing the broader results that led to scrutiny in the first place.

A familiar United pattern

The match recalled United’s 3-2 win over Newcastle in 2018, when José Mourinho was under pressure after a poor start to the season. United conceded twice early, then rallied. Anthony Martial scored, and Alexis Sánchez completed the comeback.

The roles aren’t an exact match, but the echoes are clear: Fernandes had previously challenged the team’s tactics, while Cunha delivered the decisive late goals. The question is whether this result gives Carrick breathing room, as the Newcastle win did for Mourinho, or proves to be a brief reprieve.

Mourinho was dismissed by December 2018. In the 10 games before the Newcastle match, his United side had won three times. Over the 13 games that followed, they recorded five wins, four draws and four defeats, including draws against Chelsea and Arsenal. That run extended Mourinho’s time in charge, but it wasn’t enough to meet the expectations placed on United.

A similar record over Carrick’s next 13 matches might keep him in the job, particularly if club executives remain divided over a replacement. But that remains a projection; the immediate priority is another win.

Villa is the next measure

Carrick’s United face Aston Villa on Sunday. Unai Emery is widely regarded as one of the Premier League’s leading managers, and many United supporters would want him considered if the club changes coach. A victory over Villa would give Carrick a chance to strengthen his position against a formidable opponent, with the players’ confidence lifted by the comeback.

The match may offer a clearer indication of whether the Roma performance can carry into the next fixture. Carrick’s future won’t be decided by Fernandes’ comments alone; the result at Old Trafford will matter more.

Manchester United vs Aston Villa kicks off at 4.30pm on Sunday, live on Sky Sports.

Source: William Rodriguez · www.skysports.com