FanGraphs’ Top 50 MLB Free Agents: A Thin Class and Uncertain Market

Tarik Skubal is the winter’s clear prize. The rest of the free agent class is a much tougher sell: unusually thin at the top, shaped by a looming labor fight, and full of uncertainty about what teams will be willing to spend. FanGraphs’ annual top 50 is meant to make sense of that market—and to show where the interesting bets might be once the obvious one is gone.
This is my sixth year leading the exercise. Dave Cameron, Kiley McDaniel, and Craig Edwards handled it before me, and the list remains a staff effort: FanGraphs writers contributed throughout. The rankings below reflect my preference among players, which usually tracks with projected contract value but doesn’t always. A player I expect to earn less can still rank ahead of someone with a larger forecast. The list is not simply ordered by guaranteed dollars.
You’ll find estimated contracts and market analysis for the top 25, plus player evaluations for all 50 from Davy Andrews (DA), Michael Baumann (MB), Brendan Gawlowski (BG), Jay Jaffe (JJ), David Laurila (DL), Eric Longenhagen (EL), Matt Martell (MM), Kiri Oler (KO), Matthew Roberson (MR), and Dan Szymborski (DS). Those perspectives will sometimes cross over: a player’s skills affect his market, and market expectations shape how we assess the player. Together, they should give a fuller sense of both the likely deals and what comes next in each career.
Meg Rowley served as a sounding board. Eric Longenhagen and Brendan Gawlowski helped extensively with my evaluations of international players; Jason Martinez and Jon Becker brought market expertise; Dan Szymborski helped early with projections; and Sean Dolinar provided technical assistance.
The contract figures are estimated guarantees. They exclude team options, player opt-outs, vesting options, and performance incentives. Unless stated otherwise, the projections are Steamer’s 2027 forecasts, using FanGraphs’ Depth Chart playing-time allocations. Ages refer to the season each player is about to enter, and each player’s crowdsourced forecast will appear beside mine. FanGraphs’ Free Agent Tracker has the full list of this year’s free agents; it will be updated as players sign and as crowdsourced results come in for those whose future deals were polled.
A thin class meets a looming lockout
This is the shallowest free agent class in my six years running the list, and probably the thinnest in quite a while. Some of that is ordinary chance. Some comes down to extensions that took major names off the board. Jesús Luzardo, Nico Hoerner, Chris Sale, and Max Muncy extended this spring. Garrett Crochet and Alejandro Kirk had already extended in 2025. Drew Rasmussen signed a short extension with a 2027 team option, while a vesting option kept Yandy Díaz from joining the market as another veteran slugger. Any of those decisions could have made this class look meaningfully different.
Then there’s the labor dispute. MLB is preparing to lock out players this winter as part of its collective bargaining strategy. During a lockout, teams and players can’t communicate, so negotiations and deals stop. A prolonged dispute could also shorten the 2027 season and cut into club revenue. That outcome isn’t inevitable, but teams tend to budget for trouble as though it might arrive.
The last CBA negotiation, in 2021–22, didn’t stop free agents from getting paid. Deals came in a rush before the lockout, then the market went quiet for months, followed by another burst before spring training. But the current talks are different: both sides are proposing changes that could reshape baseball’s economics. The league’s hard-cap-and-salary-floor proposal would remake the market, and any phased rollout could affect 2027 budgets. The union’s plan would be less sweeping, but a soft floor and changes to television revenue sharing would still shift team spending. Those are opening positions, and the details will change as negotiations proceed. It’s too soon to know what the final system will look like.
That uncertainty could push teams away from long contracts this winter. Clubs above possible cap lines may wait to see what rules they’ll face; clubs below a potential floor may need to plan how to spend their way into compliance. The result could be a strange split: some thriftier teams may have to take on more payroll in the years ahead, while the Yankees or Dodgers might prefer to hold off on long-term commitments until the rules are clearer.
And yet, waiting has a cost. I expect Tarik Skubal to want a deal before the game’s financial structure is renegotiated. A team will probably accept the risk and offer him a record contract in November. If you’re a club looking for a superstar, you may not get another chance at him after a lockout begins.
One clear ace, then a steep drop
Skubal stands alone at the top. He’s the clear choice for the winter’s best free agent and should set a new record among full-time pitchers—though Shohei Ohtani makes any unqualified claim about pitcher records awkward. An elbow injury scare didn’t derail Skubal’s season. He returned quickly, made 26 starts, posted a 2.72 ERA, and finished with several ERA estimators even lower. He’s an ace by any practical definition, and almost every team would be better for having him.
The gap behind him is the point. Several clubs may want a capable starter, but only one free agent looks like a sure top-of-the-rotation force. Skubal’s asking price will have no close precedent, and that scarcity should intensify the bidding. There’s no comparable superstar waiting in the next tier.
Trevor Rogers, Michael King, and Freddy Peralta are solid starters, but they aren’t capital-A aces. Adrian Morejon has been a dominant reliever and may be able to handle a starter’s workload. Among hitters, Seiya Suzuki and Randy Arozarena bring power from the corner outfield spots, though both are past 30. Jazz Chisholm Jr. is younger and less predictable. NPB standout Teruaki Sato is younger still, but questions remain about whether his power-first, contact-light approach will translate to MLB and where he’ll play defense.
The class has more to offer once you look beyond the stars. Twenty of the top 50 are starting pitchers, many likely to land one- or two-year contracts at reasonable prices. There are proven closers, multi-inning left-handed relievers, veteran catchers, three center fielders, and utility players with standout tools. Multi-inning lefties could draw particular interest after the Brewers used Aaron Ashby and DL Hall in that role on their way to a World Series title.
The bottom 20 looks familiar; those players don’t typically have the leverage to avoid free agency with major extensions. The shortage is concentrated near the top. Teams filling specific holes may find useful options here. Teams hoping to add two stars and transform themselves into contenders probably won’t.
How I approached the rankings
There’s added uncertainty around which KBO and NPB players will come stateside. That’s an annual problem, but the lockout makes the choice harder: a move to MLB would mean changing leagues and adjusting to a new country in a season that could bring a shortened spring training. For players in this tier, MLB salaries may not beat their alternatives by enough to justify the disruption. I’ve included Sato, Kaima Taira, and Hiromi Itoh. Other players from those leagues would belong in the back half of the top 50 if I were confident they’d be available. I don’t expect them to be.
I’m higher than consensus on left-handed pitchers with swing-and-miss stuff. The best clubs have stocked up on lefties over the past two years, and the reason is easy to see: October opponents include lineups loaded with star left-handed hitters. The league is increasingly left-handed, too.
I also favor the youngest pitchers in this group. Outside of Skubal, there aren’t many dependable aces, so I’m drawn to upside: pitchers with the tools and time to reach playoff-starter form. Near the bottom of the list, I gave extra weight to pitchers who finished the season well. There’s plenty of judgment in separating the 46th player from the 56th; several reasonable choices fell just short. These are the 50 I prefer.
For position players, I’m skeptical of the center fielders with significant questions: Daulton Varsho, Trent Grisham, and Luis Robert Jr. Outfield defense is a skill clubs can often replace competently from the minors. I’d rather pay for offensive production that’s harder to find internally, whether that means the contact of Luis Arraez or the power of Jake Bauers. If I were building a roster, I’d compare every free agent target with what my farm system can supply and spend on the holes that are hardest to fill from within.
That’s the broad market picture behind the rankings. If you’re puzzled by a player’s spot, a group’s prominence, or an omission, those choices probably follow from the priorities above. I’ll be answering questions about the list at 2 p.m. ET today. With that context, let’s get to the players.
| Type | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 10 | $38.0 M | $380.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 8 | $42.0 M | $336.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 7.91 | $42.4 M | $335.8 M |
| IP | BB% | K% | GB% | ERA | FIP | xFIP | WAR | RA9-WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 192.0 | 5.6% | 29.4% | 43.1% | 2.88 | 2.83 | 2.93 | 5.5 | 5.7 |
Ben’s Take
Great players don’t face bad free agent markets, and Skubal is good enough to make the forecast unusually straightforward. Clubs aren’t shopping for “a Skubal type.” They want Skubal. If they need a good starter with a chance to pitch like an ace, there are alternatives; if they need a true ace, there’s only one. The central question is how far he’ll push the pitcher contract record, not whether he’ll break it.
Yoshinobu Yamamoto currently sets the benchmark with a 12-year, $325 million contract that included player perks such as opt-outs and a no-trade clause. Skubal should top that in total dollars. I expect him to favor money over convenience and set a figure future pitchers can chase.
Ten years is a long commitment for any pitcher, but it spreads the cost across more seasons. Asked to model a three-year deal, my contract model values Skubal at $65 million a year—a rate that doesn’t fit the way baseball teams budget. I expect him to sign before December, and I don’t think his deal will freeze the rest of the market the way some high-priced signings have. Skubal is a singular case this winter.
Player Notes
Skubal won the Cy Young Award in both 2024 and 2025, but the Tigers offered him $19 million in arbitration before his walk year. He challenged that figure and won the largest arbitration salary in history: $32 million.
His season then took a difficult turn. Loose bodies in his left elbow sent him to surgery. The experimental NanoNeedle Scope 2.0 procedure brought his recovery down to a month and a half, but by then Detroit’s direction was apparent. The Tigers traded him to the Dodgers for a three-player package on August 2. Skubal kept pitching like an ace, but he couldn’t deliver a third straight championship for Los Angeles on his own.
Seiya Suzuki is the best position player available, but that says as much about the thin market as it does about him. He’s coming off a career year, and his bat has been consistently productive. The catch is the price: teams may pay heavily for a 32-year-old corner outfielder whose defensive value and playing time could decline.
2. Seiya Suzuki, OF, age 32
| Contract estimate | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 4 | $27.0 M | $108.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 4 | $24.0 M | $96.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 3.79 | $23.7 M | $89.8 M |
2027 Steamer projections: 644 PA, 11.5% BB, 24.7% K, .256 AVG, .346 OBP, .447 SLG, .346 wOBA, 120 wRC+, 13.6 Off, -9.3 Def, 2.7 WAR.
Suzuki’s 2026 season—4.5 WAR, 26 home runs, and Gold Glove finalist recognition—puts him in position to earn a major deal. Ben Clemens projects four years and $108 million; crowd estimates cluster lower, around four years and $90–96 million. A contract worth 75% less guaranteed money than Tarik Skubal’s would still make Suzuki a top-paid hitter in this class. If he stays healthy and keeps delivering at a corner, he has an All-Star level bat for the next few seasons.
The bat is the safer bet. Across five major league seasons, Suzuki’s lowest wRC+ is 118. He pairs patience, contact, and power well enough to absorb a slump in one area without becoming an easy out. Clubs have grown wary of long commitments to hitters in their 30s, but Suzuki fits the profile that can still command one: a productive hitter with few obvious weaknesses.
Here’s the constraint: he’s a right-handed corner outfielder who has already started 28 games at DH in his walk year. That workload could grow as he ages, and his defense is difficult to project after four years of poor metrics followed by an above-average season in right. Since coming to the U.S. in 2022, he ranks 55th among qualified position players in WAR and 24th in wRC+. Those are strong results, though not the profile of a risk-free centerpiece.
The market gives buyers few alternatives if they need a middle-of-the-order hitter. There was a time when a club could weigh options such as Aaron Judge, Trea Turner, and Willson Contreras. This winter, Suzuki is the standout. He began his MLB career with 14 homers and a .336 OBP as a rookie, then improved his in-zone contact and lifted his walk rate into double digits while maintaining his bat speed. His 4.5 WAR in 2026 was a career high. The back end of his next contract could get uncomfortable, but he’s the class’s best position player. – MB
3. Trevor Rogers, SP, age 29
| Contract estimate | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 4 | $26.0 M | $104.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 5 | $24.0 M | $120.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 4.36 | $23.7 M | $103.3 M |
2027 Steamer projections: 175 IP, 7.0% BB, 22.4% K, 40.7% GB, 3.82 ERA, 3.83 FIP, 3.91 xFIP, 3.2 WAR, 3.1 RA9-WAR.
Rogers is a persuasive bet because he’s young, left-handed, and recently effective. At 29, he’s among the youngest free agents on the board. By fWAR, he was the second-best pitcher in this class in 2026, and multiple ERA estimators support the performance. His fastball-heavy approach may also attract teams that believe they can refine his pitch mix. That potential is an added attraction, though the results already make a strong case.
The health record is the obvious reservation. Rogers has missed roughly two seasons’ worth of time to injury, and his 2024 start in Baltimore was rough: four poor outings, then a demotion. But the Orioles’ bet that he could recover his 2021 form soon proved right. After the season, Rogers worked with Driveline, rebuilding strength after a back injury, adjusting his delivery, and changing his sweeper grip. A dislocated knee delayed his 2025 debut, but once back, he added more than a tick of fastball velocity and showed much better command. The sweeper quickly emerged as a standout pitch.
Over the past two seasons, Rogers has a 3.20 FIP and 7.3 WAR across 48 starts, ranking 17th among starters in both categories. He threw a career-high 169 2/3 innings in 2026. That’s enough to make him a credible mid-rotation anchor, though his injury history keeps the ceiling and floor far apart. Left-handed pitching also carries extra appeal for teams facing lineups such as the Yankees, Dodgers, and Brewers. A nine-figure deal is plausible, even in a market with several high-end lefties. – BG
4. Michael King, SP, age 32
| Contract estimate | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 4 | $25.0 M | $100.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 4 | $25.0 M | $100.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 3.98 | $25.6 M | $102.0 M |
2027 Steamer projections: 180 IP, 8.5% BB, 22.1% K, 42.4% GB, 4.07 ERA, 4.11 FIP, 4.09 xFIP, 2.5 WAR, 2.5 RA9-WAR.
King opted out of a deal with two years and $53 million left after a 2026 season that brought career highs in starts and innings and 2.6 WAR. He missed half of 2025, so the rebound mattered; it still didn’t match his dominant 2024. A return to San Diego on a revised contract seems possible, especially given the Padres’ willingness under A.J. Preller to pay to retain their own players. As a free agent, King remains a strong option.
The warning signs are real. In 2026, he recorded career lows in swinging-strike and strikeout rates, alongside career highs in walk rate, xFIP, xERA, and SIERA. A low BABIP and high strand rate helped cushion those weaker indicators, and it’s hard to assume those will repeat. The projection systems see a good starter rather than an elite one. I’d still pay for his reliability and flexibility, but the gap between his best and expected versions matters.
King’s path to this point is unusual: a 12th-round pick who found a role in the Yankees’ bullpen, then became one of the game’s more successful converted starters. Shoulder nerve trouble and knee pain cost him time in 2025. Across three years with the Padres, he put up 7.5 WAR, a 3.15 ERA, and a 3.86 FIP in 432 innings, plus six solid postseason appearances; he was healthy throughout 2026. Alongside Rogers and Freddy Peralta, he has a case as the class’s second-best starter behind Skubal.
His strikeout rate fell, but contact rates haven’t climbed by the same measure, so there may be room for a rebound. King’s mix is direct: sinkers, four-seamers, and sweepers to everyone, with changeups to lefties and sliders to righties. Teams that won’t pursue Skubal can use an arm like this, and King should draw interest even with uncertainty over the next CBA. – DS
5. Teruaki Sato, 3B/RF, age 28
| Contract estimate | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 5 | $22.0 M | $110.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 5 | $20.0 M | $100.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 4.52 | $19.6 M | $88.6 M |
2027 ZiPS projections: 607 PA, 9.2% BB, 32.1% K, .254 AVG, .326 OBP, .471 SLG, .339 wOBA, 118 wRC+, 25 HR, 2.9 WAR.
Sato’s power is easy to see; the contact risk is just as obvious. Like Munetaka Murakami, he’s an NPB bat-first third baseman who can also play right field. He has plus-plus power and a swing built to lift the ball, but his miss rate is alarming. In NPB, he swung through pitches as often as Colson Montgomery did in MLB during the season Montgomery set the single-season strikeout record. That comparison doesn’t mean Sato will repeat it in the majors, but it shows how wide the projection range is.
His defense grades below average at both third and right. Some teams may see him at first base; others could use him as a rotating corner player and live with the glove for the power. That makes him a difficult fit for a contender that needs predictable production. Still, the upside is substantial: if the bat translates and he can remain at third, he could become a perennial All-Star. An emerging team may be more willing to take that bet, as the White Sox did with Murakami last year. Sato is young enough that a successful first season could pay off for years.
Four teams named Sato as their first-round choice in the 2020 NPB draft, sending his rights to Hanshin in a lottery. The college draftee made the big-league club in 2021, striking out 38% as a rookie, then settled in before breaking out as a power hitter in 2025. Over the past two seasons, he has averaged 40 home runs and 80 extra-base hits. He won the Central League MVP in 2025 after taking the league’s triple crown and is the presumptive favorite to win again in 2026.
The scouting report backs up the numbers: Sato does his loudest damage on low pitches, sometimes generating power through a full-body swing and sometimes through his hands alone. He tends to pull middle-down pitches, especially softer offerings that don’t finish beneath the zone. His 2026 marks—56% hard-hit rate, 108 mph EV90, and 116 mph maximum exit velocity—are all plus. There’s 30-homer power here. The question is how much contact comes with it. – Ben Clemens
Sato’s bat can probably survive some missed swings. The bigger question is whether his power will make enough contact worthwhile: in 2026, he connected on just 67% of pitches overall and on fastballs, missing heaters at the same rate that [Cam Schlittler](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/cam-schlittler/32095/stats/pitching) got swings and misses. That’s a real warning sign. Recent third basemen who produced with contact rates below 70% include [Nolan Gorman](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/nolan-gorman/22263/stats/batting), [Jake Burger](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/jake-burger/22275/stats/batting) and [Mark Vientos](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/mark-vientos/22184/stats/batting). [Kazuma Okamoto](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/kazuma-okamoto/37123/stats/batting), [Ryan McMahon](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/ryan-mcmahon/15112/stats/batting), Max Muncy and [Eugenio Suárez](https://www.fangraphs.com/players/eugenio-suarez/12552/stats/batting) sit right around 70%. More low-contact hitters have found ways to produce across the majors, including recent NPB arrival Munetaka Murakami, whose 60% rate was the lowest in baseball. Sato’s whiffs leave a meaningful bust risk, but his power gives him a path to value. His glove complicates the fit. Sato splits time between third base and right field, and his throwing accuracy on the infield is a concern. A team may want to place him where opponents are least likely to put the ball in play; a club that sees him as a dependable third baseman could instead keep him there.Freddy Peralta’s strikeout dip needs context
Peralta is the sort of pitcher whose reputation can run ahead of his latest numbers. He has looked like an ace at times, but his 2026 season was a step down, and the decline in strikeouts gives teams a reason to hesitate. The Rays didn’t simply “fix” him after the Mets “broke” him; that story makes too much of a small sample. Peralta has long depended on whiffs, and his strikeout rate fell from a previous full-season low of 27.1% to 22.1% with New York and 19.7% with Tampa Bay. His playoff run was encouraging on the surface, but it included 10 walks and 16 strikeouts over 21⅓ innings. The longer record still counts. Peralta’s peripherals with the Mets suggested better pitching than his headline results, and his .339 xwOBACON was his lowest since 2022. New York’s defense was below average overall at -2 FRV, then fell to -6 FRV behind him in 113⅔ innings; just eight pitchers who threw at least 110 innings faced worse defense. Tampa Bay recorded 7 FRV behind him in 55⅓ innings. The defensive gap helps explain why the results changed, though it doesn’t account for the full strikeout decline. The Rays also changed how Peralta attacked hitters. He leaned more on his changeup and dropped a slider that had allowed a .402 wOBA in 2026 after yielding .197 in 2025. They also helped him [adjust his delivery](https://www.mlb.com/news/freddy-peralta-finding-success-with-rays-after-adjustments), raising his arm angle slightly and adding extension, which increased the perceived velocity of his pitches. Those changes offer a plausible route back to above-average seasons, but clubs will still have to price in the fading strikeout numbers and his age-31 season in 2027. His style also shapes the market. Peralta nibbles, runs up pitch counts and often leaves games early, so he may suit teams comfortable leaning on their bullpens. I’d expect a discount in either annual value or contract length. A big home park and strong outfield defense could help him beat his peripherals again, as Tampa Bay’s stint suggests he doesn’t need to strike out everyone to succeed.| Type | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 4 | $23.0 M | $92.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 4 | $24.0 M | $96.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 3.96 | $23.5 M | $92.9 M |
| IP | BB% | K% | GB% | ERA | FIP | xFIP | WAR | RA9-WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 169.0 | 8.8% | 22.4% | 37.6% | 4.33 | 4.32 | 4.29 | 1.9 | 1.9 |
Jazz Chisholm Jr. is a high-variance bet
Chisholm’s combination of power and speed is unusual for a second baseman, and a 30-homer threat who can defend up the middle has obvious appeal. But the downside case is just as easy to see: he struck out nearly 30% of the time in 2026, hit below league average, and remains inconsistent in the field. A team can reasonably project either a productive bat or a strong glove; counting on both at once is a tougher bet. If neither reaches its ceiling, the result could be an ordinary second baseman with limited free-agent appeal. That uncertainty makes contract structure part of the story. Chisholm may prefer fewer guaranteed years and an opt-out, or a shorter deal with incentives and escalators that let him return to the market if he rebounds. I settled on a projection near the best straightforward guarantee he could get, but the range of outcomes is wide—and his outlook was brighter a year ago. The contrast with his 2025 peak is sharp. He posted a .242/.332/.481 line, a 125 wRC+ and career highs of 31 homers, 31 steals and 4.3 WAR, then set a public target of 50 homers and 50 steals for 2026. Instead, he finished at .231/.312/.399 with a 98 wRC+, 19 homers and 41 steals. His swing slowed from 73.9 mph to 72.9, he chased more pitches outside the zone than at any point since 2021—especially fastballs and curveballs—and his contact quality slipped. Barrel rate fell from 15% to 8.2%, while xSLG dropped from .481 to .366. The extra strikeouts made that loss of impact harder to absorb.| Type | Years | AAV | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ben Clemens | 4 | $23.0 M | $92.0 M |
| Median Crowdsource | 4 | $23.0 M | $92.0 M |
| Avg Crowdsource | 4.14 | $22.9 M | $94.6 M |
| PA | BB% | K% | AVG | OBP | SLG | wOBA | wRC+ | Off | Def | WAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 560 | 10.2% | 26.9% | .234 | .317 | .408 | .318 | 101 | 3.3 | 3.0 | 2.6 |