A free-agent forecast with unusually wide margins
The clearest takeaway from Ben Clemens’s chat is how little confidence he has in this year’s free-agent projections. He calls the class the weakest he’s covered as a baseball writer, says it’s the first time he’s forecast less total spending than the previous class, and describes the coming collective bargaining agreement as a major source of uncertainty. “I’ve never been less confident in a list than this one,” he says. That candor matters: the rankings are estimates in a market where both the talent and the rules are unusually hard to read.
Clemens expects shorter contracts than the market may, and says contract length is the biggest broad judgment call in his forecast. His method for handling the recent split between long deals and short contracts with high annual values is largely subjective: he prices several possible contract lengths and chooses what seems plausible overall. He also expects the middle of the list to find buyers, partly because teams may spend before a lockout. A spending spree for the class’s second tier is possible; a repeat of last year’s huge deals for players such as Tucker and Bichette seems less likely, given the thinner group at the top.
His player-level disagreements show where the forecast gets especially subjective. Clemens is higher on Kris Bubic than he expects teams to be, even while acknowledging that his contract estimate may exceed Bubic’s eventual deal. He’s cooler on Arozarena than many other forecasters, who place him near the top five. Among the pitchers farther down his list, Matt Boyd, Brandon Woodruff and Kevin Gausman also stand out as possible points of disagreement.
The international players bring a different kind of uncertainty. Clemens says Taira’s role is hard to pin down and his pitching style has few close comparisons; age and fastball quality make him want to rank Taira higher. Sato is difficult to value because Clemens was too optimistic about last year’s NPB class, yet sees traits in Sato that remind him of Munetaka Murakami. ZiPS rates Sato as the class’s second-best player, though Clemens stresses the projection has wide error bars. He also believes Murakami was underpaid, and says Murakami’s strong performance in Chicago may be changing how teams assess players coming from Japan. In his view, Sato’s appeal includes defensive flexibility and the possibility of better contact than expected.
A few decisions came down to the narrow margins between players. Clemens says Jazz Chisholm was always in his top 10, with a place after Suzuki and before Arozarena, though predicting Chisholm’s contract was difficult. Paul Blackburn missed the top 50 after Emilio Pagán opted out and took the final spot; Clemens says roughly 20 relievers had similar projections, and Blackburn sat at the bottom of the group for much of the process. He also projects Luis Arraez at two years and $38 million, versus two years and $28 million for Gleyber Torres. Those estimates are close, and Clemens questions the assumption that Torres is likely to out-slug Arraez: from 2024–26, Torres had a .378 slugging percentage over 1,700 plate appearances, while Arraez had a .400 mark over 2,000.
The chat opened with a Brewers fan asking whether the site would publish a managerial report card for Pat Murphy after Milwaukee’s World Series win. Clemens said Jon Becker and Dan Szymborski handled the AL and NL report cards, respectively, while he focused on the free-agent list. Another reader joked about a snubbed “Player X”; Clemens played along, calling that player overrated and saying “player Y” was ranked too low. He also mentioned that Emilio Pagán’s opt-out the previous day forced a late change to the top 50.
These exchanges sketch the article’s larger problem: a ranking can look precise while resting on uncertain assumptions about playing time, contract length, the market and the next labor agreement. Clemens has done the work, but he’s clear about the limits of the result. For anyone using these projections to judge a team’s offseason plans, that uncertainty belongs in the headline, too.
Health risk, contract length and the shape of the market
The biggest uncertainty in this class may be what teams know that the public doesn’t. Asked why the Padres might decline Nick Pivetta’s option, Ben Clemens said there was no public explanation. Fangraphs’ staff had discussed the case and concluded that the medical picture would have to be alarming for San Diego to pass on him. Pivetta’s production made a two-year, $32 million deal look appealing to one reader, especially after he finished the season looking healthy. Clemens said Pivetta had been a serious candidate for the list, but the health question was hard to ignore.
Sonny Gray presents a different kind of risk. Clemens would be comfortable paying him $25 million or more for one season, and sees him as a pitcher who deserves a major salary on a playoff contender. The hesitation is duration: he’d prefer a year by year arrangement, even at a high annual value. Gray keeps succeeding despite doubts about his velocity, but Clemens acknowledged that he could eventually “turn into a pumpkin.” For now, he hasn’t.
That distinction—confidence in a player’s immediate value, uncertainty about how long it lasts—runs through the contract discussion. Clemens said Gray was tied for second in his projected pitching average annual value, while also suggesting Gray himself might not want to remain on a long deal once he stopped pitching well.
Projections under a cloud
Clemens usually starts with individual contract estimates, then checks them against the overall market. He trusts his read on group trends more than his ability to predict unusual details in any one deal. If pitchers as a class appear likely to command a certain level of money, that aggregate view can help keep individual projections grounded.
This free-agent cycle has put that method under strain. The collective bargaining agreement is unsettled, clouding the broader market. The qualifying-offer picture was uncertain too: the schedule for publishing the projections meant the list wasn’t ready, and Clemens wasn’t confident about which players would receive offers. Had the World Series ended in a sweep, he said, the list likely would have been available. With the recipients unknown, he didn’t want to guess who might accept; if the list had been clear, he would have projected at least one acceptance.
That uncertainty also makes it difficult to say how much less money this class will earn than the previous one. Clemens wouldn’t simply cut every player’s projection by a fixed percentage if the total came out too high. He does, however, use the classwide numbers as a check. The overall market is easier to forecast than the quirks of any single contract—and this year, even that larger picture is unusually murky.
Outliers and scarcity
Taira is compelling precisely because the answer is still unclear. One reader wondered whether his profile could be undervalued, comparing him with Jose Altuve and imagining the challenge of facing Taira after Noah Schultz. Clemens said he didn’t know how well the style would work, but that uncertainty was part of the appeal. He likes unusual arm angles and release points when a pitcher can repeat his mechanics, and compared the fascination to watching Murakami this year.
Taira is listed at 5-foot-8 and 220 pounds, prompting a comparison with Bartolo Colon. Clemens sees a more unusual pitcher: a high-velocity four-seam fastball from an exceptionally low release point. He also mentioned a resemblance to “tiny Miz,” despite Miz being enormous: a defining fastball, secondaries that benefit from its plane and angle, and room for better command. Eric likes Taira’s splitter, Clemens said, but the fastball is likely to be the signature pitch.
The scarcity of options could also create a surprise payday for Randy Arozarena. If a team wants a proven slugger and misses out on Suzuki, there aren’t many alternatives, Clemens said. He doesn’t expect Arozarena to land an unexpectedly rich contract, but admitted scarcity is difficult to capture in a numerical projection. You can sense it; putting a number on it is harder.
Where the fun is
Asked which player-team pairings he’d like to see, Clemens backed Michael Soroka with the Blue Jays and imagined Alec Bohm in Coors Field, a suggestion credited to Cespedes BBQ. Emilio Pagan in Colorado might be entertaining for less flattering reasons. Taira joining the Brewers would be his favorite fit, though he thinks it’s highly unlikely.
Clemens also explained why he won’t write report cards for managers who missed the postseason. Much of a manager’s regular-season value—keeping players prepared, maintaining team cohesion, handling depth charts and managing pitching staffs—is difficult to measure from the outside. That’s a useful reminder about the limits of evaluating baseball through results alone.
His playoff favorites were more personal and immediate. He enjoyed Brewers and Rays games, especially Milwaukee’s run: his wife is from the city, and her mother has season tickets. They went to the series; Clemens didn’t. He singled out Michael King returning on no days’ rest and Nick Martinez pitching in the World Series, along with the connection between Jake Bauers, Sal Frelick and Jeff Passan, Pat Murphy teasing Cooper Pratt, and Patrick Bailey pinch-hitting for Austin Hedges.
The chat briefly turned to lunch: Clemens had a Factor meal kit, part of a household habit of switching meal services based on discounts and how busy they are. He hoped the offseason would bring more free time—and more interesting lunches. The final question asked whether this was the most mediocre free-agent class he’d rated, and suggested it could be the subject of a future analysis.
Free-agent projections leave a thinner top tier
The free-agent pool looks unusually light by projection, Ben Clemens said, largely because more of the top-end players than usual signed extensions. The middle of the list resembles past versions of his exercise, but the projected talent at the top is thinner. That distinction matters: a familiar-looking market can still offer fewer players capable of moving the needle.
Taira is a good example of the uncertainty in this pool. Clemens expects him to end up in relief, though he thinks whichever team offers the most may be betting hardest on his chance to start. Taira didn’t start often in NPB, but he got a chance to do so this year; a signing team may give him another look before settling on the bullpen. Clemens sees his style as better suited to relief over the long term, while stressing that the forecast carries wide error bars.
Small samples can sway a player’s price
Clemens thinks Mize hurt his standing with his performance for the Padres. He builds two versions of his free-agent list: an early September ranking based on instinct and a playoff-period version informed by projections and deeper statistical review. Comparing them helps expose his own biases. In Mize’s case, the first list ranked him much higher because Clemens put too much weight on the first half of the season, his upward trajectory, and the appeal of a former first overall pick with good stuff.
The caveat cuts both ways. Mize’s recent struggles came in a small sample, but so did his strong stretch. A pitcher who’s currently dealing can make a short run feel more convincing than the evidence supports.
Milwaukee’s decision to keep Kyle Harrison on its roster through all three playoff series without using him also drew comment. Clemens said the Brewers had tried him late in the regular season, when he wasn’t looking sharp, but kept the upside available in case they needed it. Their wins and comfortable margins meant they never did. The roster spot proved unused, though the team’s success meant it never became costly.
Payroll rules remain unsettled
A question about whether a possible payroll floor could make the Brewers more likely to bring back Bauers prompted Clemens to push back on the premise. A cap and floor may emerge, he said, or the league could adopt a hybrid arrangement; the eventual figures are too uncertain to call. Whatever the system, a major economic change would probably be phased in. Requiring the Nationals and Marlins to roughly double payroll while the Dodgers cut theirs by two-thirds all at once would be unworkable, in his view, and a transition period would reduce pressure on this year’s contracts.
There was also a suggestion that Randy Arozarena’s value as a “Proven Slugger” might appeal to Dave Dombrowski. Clemens agreed that Philadelphia would be a plausible destination, describing Arozarena as a next-generation version of Nick Castellanos in some respects.
The common thread is uncertainty: projected value, role, playoff performance and potential payroll rules all leave room for teams to see the same player or market differently. For anyone tracking this free-agent class, that makes the projections useful as a baseline—but a poor substitute for knowing what a particular club believes it can change.