A quieter offseason chat, with plenty to evaluate
Brendan Gawlowski opened his November 3 FanGraphs chat expecting a light queue. That may be the offseason talking, though the questions quickly ranged from prospect rankings to player development and the oddities of minor league baseball.
The most useful early update was on Zion Rose: Gawlowski said Rose had improved enough in Arizona to move from his previous draft position onto FanGraphs’ top 100 list. He also offered a reminder that prospect evaluation can hinge on strange moments. Yanquiel Fernandez launched a ball 47 feet beyond the foul pole, was called foul, then hit an even longer drive to right-center on the next pitch. In another game, Modesto broke an eighth-inning scoreless tie when a wild pitch struck the catcher’s shin guard and bounced into the dugout, letting the only run score. Juan Guerrero, meanwhile, played hacky sack with his glove in left field as his pitcher came set.
Roster puzzles and development plans
Several questions focused on where players might fit. Gawlowski sees Angel Genao’s possible move to left field as premature: his infield situation could change through a trade, a chance to replace Rocchio, or a move to second base if Bazzana shifts elsewhere. He said a Bazzana bat around 110 wRC+ over the long term could work in a corner, while stressing that he wasn’t predicting a position change. Asked to choose between nine Chandler Simpsons and nine Yandys, he picked the Yandys, while conceding the matchup would be a mess.
For Brewers left-hander Wande Torres, a long-term starting role remains possible, but Gawlowski sees a relief outcome as far more likely—roughly an 80/20 or 90/10 split. Torres lacks looseness and fluidity and already walks a fair number of hitters. Chicago, by contrast, has reason to give Grant Taylor a shot in the rotation; Gawlowski thinks he can start, with closing or an Andy Ashby type role as alternatives.
Jarlin Susana’s command problems call for a tailored development plan, Gawlowski said. Coaches and development staff will weigh possible physical adjustments against the likelihood of improving his command, then set a winter workout and throwing program and reassess him in spring training. That’s a useful glimpse of how teams approach a difficult projection: make a plan, then see what the work changes.
The conversation also touched on the broader farm system. Gawlowski pointed to athletic assessments, individualized strength and conditioning, experiments with bat handles and barrel shapes, and pitch design labs. Farm directors, he added, rely heavily on people management: they must align players, coaches, trainers, and front office staff across different backgrounds and approaches. That skill can translate to managing a major league club, though the job brings different demands.
Lists, labor rules, and a preview
Gawlowski said the Red Sox prospect list was scheduled earlier this offseason simply because he picked the timing “out of a hat,” metaphorically. He hoped list season would start the following week and offered an early look at Braves prospect Luis Guanipa.
Guanipa, a $2.5 million international signee from Venezuela in the 2023 class, is 20. Gawlowski described him as neither especially toolsy nor projectable, with a profile much like last year’s. Guanipa makes frequent contact—77% overall and 84% in the zone last year—but rarely hits the ball with authority. He often swings inside the ball and sends it the other way. His bat speed is average; he reliably pulls offspeed pitches mainly when they hang over the middle or inner part of the plate. His approach and swing decisions are generally sound, but he chased more spin off the plate this year and barely walked after a late-season move to High-A.
In the field, Guanipa shows both good reads and routes that drift. Gawlowski sees a player who can handle center field without standing out there, and who may have lost a half-step since the last evaluation. A fourth-outfielder role remains plausible, but some strengths look less secure than they did in the lower minors, and Guanipa has slipped in the updated ranking.
Other exchanges were shorter. Asked for a scout-friendly change to the collective bargaining agreement, Gawlowski proposed moving the draft to June. He declined to publish a question built around stereotypes about players’ motivation based on nationality. And he promised to check back the following week with more information on Mariners prospect Po-Chun Lin, saying the question required more research than a live chat allowed.
The chat also briefly veered into chess: a user with an 880-ish rating asked whether that meant Rookie Ball, and Gawlowski guessed it was around the 60th percentile on Chess.com. One reader wondered whether the offseason might bring articles written to fill a prolonged lockout. The fragment ends before Gawlowski answers.
What the evaluations can—and can’t—tell you
The most useful thread here is how much prospect evaluation depends on judgment, even when the question sounds like it should have a clean statistical answer. One reader asked why other clubs can’t copy the Brewers’ reputation for bat design. Brendan Gawlowski said he couldn’t assess Milwaukee against the rest of the league, and stressed that other teams are experimenting too. He recalled a report—though he couldn’t locate it—about Julio testing different bat handles and passing on the one that produced his highest maximum exit velocity because it didn’t feel right. That’s a good reminder: a better number in a controlled test doesn’t automatically make a better fit for a hitter.
The torpedo bat came up as a recent example of the Brewers’ involvement in bat design. Gawlowski corrected the attribution: the opening-weekend controversy last year originated with the Yankees, though he agreed it was relevant to the discussion.
Scouting grades can swing sharply, but the biggest moves often start with players who had little notice. Gawlowski pointed to very young prospects going from off the radar to a 40-plus grade in a year, with Texas’s Breyner Figuereo a possible candidate. The opposite happens too: some players who receive significant signing money in the Dominican Summer League begin as 40 or 40-plus prospects and then show they aren’t good. He named Kendry Martinez and Cristopher Polanco.
A reader cited Vance Honeycutt as a case of a dramatic fall: from a 45 future value in 2025 to honorable mention in 2026, then back to a 40 FV. Gawlowski suspected there were even more extreme examples. The point is that a grade records an evaluator’s view at a moment in time; it isn’t a promise that a player’s trajectory will stay smooth.
That caution also applies to pitchers with exciting stuff but little track record. Gawlowski said he and Eric might discuss a 100 grade based on pitch shape, but generally want to see a pitcher hold his stuff over longer stretches first. Briggs McKenzie is a player they like; Gawlowski said he’d give him a mid-rotation grade if scouting for a team, while reserving the top grade until there’s more evidence.
Development, opportunity, and team fit
The minor league reorganization may be speeding up the path for a small group of players who are racing through the system, Gawlowski said. They could reach the majors sooner than they would have under the structure in place ten years ago. He didn’t suggest the change benefits every prospect type.
Team context can shape a player’s chances, too. Gawlowski said the analysts try to flag when a draftee lands in a particularly good or poor fit for his talents. Asked for a quick example of a bad destination for a pitcher, he joked that Colorado drafting one nearly answers the question.
For the White Sox’s Smith, Schultz, and McDougal, Gawlowski emphasized that his outlook was speculation: Schultz should get every opportunity to start, Smith could become a relief ace, and McDougal may play a smaller role. For Sebastian Walcott, he took the over on whether the prospect would accumulate more than 450 major league innings at shortstop. If Walcott reaches the majors in 2027, though, Gawlowski expects the outfield to be the initial landing spot, with Corey Seager still productive at short.
Other evaluations were similarly qualified. Gawlowski thinks Caminiti’s changeup is improving year over year and expects him to make the grade, though the question of whether his other pitches are enough remains one to discuss. On the Red Sox list, he thought Delzine might just make it, put Primera at “PTC,” and was less bullish on Godbout than he had been the previous May.
The ball itself may complicate pitcher comparisons. Asked how the minor league ball affects evaluations relative to the major league ball, Gawlowski said the effect doesn’t appear uniform. He suspects pitchers who rely on an overhand, high-carry fastball may be affected more than others, but said more analysis is needed to determine whether that’s a real trend or anecdotal impression.
How the chat works
Gawlowski said the question queue had picked up, but his process is straightforward: he scans what readers have submitted and usually starts with questions he can answer quickly. He keeps spreadsheets open and sometimes pulls up video for a player he knows but wants to reassess. For a question about Wande Torres, for instance, he watched video in the background while answering other questions. When a topic needs more preparation, he asks readers to return the following week so he can research it.
He’s heard that his replies can feel terse. His explanation was practical: he’d rather answer more questions than write at length on fewer of them.
There were a few other quick reads. Asked whether Arias resembles Gleyber Torres with better defense, Gawlowski said the comparison didn’t excite him—but added that a 113 wRC+ over a player’s first nine seasons, as Torres produced, would make that player a star. And when asked whether a version of the Rule 5 draft might happen that offseason, he said it was possible but unlikely; teams’ 40-man roster decisions would change if they knew for certain either way.
The fragment ends with a question about whether Bodine or Gillen could debut in 2027, without an answer.
Development delays could send fringe players overseas
The uncertainty around development time may be enough to change where some borderline free agents play. Brendan Gawlowski said he could imagine more players taking contracts abroad rather than losing time to a stalled season, including a few more pitchers in the mold of Dan Straily joining KBO clubs. That’s a plausible response, though it remains speculation.
A late-season surge can also invite more confidence than the evidence supports. Asked about Bishop Letson’s finish, Gawlowski pulled up his 2026 game logs and was impressed, but said he’d want to compare the pitcher’s September work with July before drawing a firm conclusion. [The game log](https://www.baseball-reference.com/register/player.fcgi?id=letson000bis&type=pgl&year=2026) is a useful starting point; it can’t establish whether the change will stick.
Gawlowski has seen that pattern before. He bought into Case Williams after the pitcher added velocity and missed bats late in 2022, only for the velocity jump to disappear the following spring. The caution applies to any hot finish: it may signal real development, or a short-lived spike.
When a starter belongs in relief
For a pitcher who can work multiple innings, the clearest warning sign may be how quickly starts unravel. Gawlowski pointed to the starter who looks effective early, then gets into trouble around the third or fourth inning. That pattern can make a multi-inning relief role a better fit, though the brief exchange offered no broader rule for when to stop trying a pitcher as a starter. Aaron Ashby was raised as an example in the question.
The people tracking prospects
There’s a lot of value in close, local coverage of farm systems. Gawlowski praised Roger’s work at There R Giants, describing how he catches details such as Samir Chires throwing harder in a bullpen session. He also named Sox Prospects for Boston, Scott Lucas for Texas, Matt Winkelman for Philadelphia, and MadFriars for San Diego, while acknowledging there are other strong prospect reporters he couldn’t recall in the moment.
For readers following prospects, that kind of reporting can surface changes before they show up in a box score or a season summary. It also calls for judgment: a velocity bump is worth noticing, but Williams’s case is a reminder that one encouraging stretch doesn’t settle the question.
Rule 5 uncertainty and prospect rankings
If the Rule 5 draft is in doubt, teams with crowded 40-man rosters and many eligible players have the most reason to hope it doesn’t happen. Gawlowski jokingly objected to the word “gambling,” then named Tampa Bay, Milwaukee, and San Francisco as clubs that might be rooting for that outcome.
He was more measured on whether Zazueta is the Dodgers’ best right-handed pitching prospect in roughly 20 years. Gawlowski put him near the top, but said comparisons are complicated by hindsight: Bobby Miller was once a very good prospect, while the organization remains high on River Ryan. Prospect rankings can capture present belief; they can’t erase how uncertain the outcomes are.