Jess McClain Takes Second at NYC Marathon, Ends U.S. Women’s Podium Drought

| 5 min read

Jess McClain’s second-place finish at the New York City Marathon came down to sharp race judgment and a kick she’d practiced before the start. The 34-year-old from Scottsdale ran 2:24:42, passed Olympic medalist Hellen Obiri in the closing yards, and became the first American woman on the NYC podium since Shalane Flanagan placed third in 2018. The result carried extra weight because it wasn’t built on a comfortable day: McClain said she felt poor through much of the race, yet stayed close enough to make her move count.

A patient race, then a late move

McClain told ESPN she felt poor through the first 18 miles. The measured pace suited her: the leaders reached halfway in 1:13:52, and McClain remained in contention as the course climbed Fifth Avenue. Weini Kelati, making her marathon debut, Carrie Ellwood, and Paige Wood were also among the American women in the lead pack. Holding position through that stretch mattered more than forcing the pace; in a marathon, a runner who spends too much early can have little left when the real decisions arrive.

The decisive split came at mile 23, when Kenya’s Sheila Chepkirui and defending champion Hellen Obiri edged seven seconds clear. McClain, in a mint green Brooks kit, stayed close enough to respond. She ran the 25th mile in 5:10, then focused on her form and the shortest route through Central Park’s curves. That sequence shows how small choices can become consequential late in a race: she had to keep contact, then use the course efficiently while fatigue narrowed the margin for error.

“The last two miles through the park, I was just like really focused on the tangents and my form,” she said. McClain noticed Obiri running farther from the inside line and believed the small differences mattered. Chepkirui pulled away in the final 200 meters, winning by six seconds. McClain caught Obiri just before the line. It was a narrow finish, but the podium place came from sustained attention as much as from a final burst.

“I just felt really strong with 400 to go,” McClain said. She’d visualized the final stretch and practiced running the last 400 meters in the days before the race, including New York’s uphill finish. “I’m going to hammer it home. It’s not over till it’s over.” The preparation gave her a specific task when the finish came into view, rather than leaving the closing seconds to instinct alone.

American depth behind McClain

Three other Americans finished in the top eight. Ellwood, 32, placed sixth in 2:26:28; Kelati, 29, was seventh in 2:26:51; and Wood, 30, finished eighth in 2:27:29. Their cluster behind McClain makes the American showing broader than one athlete’s podium. It also suggests the domestic field had several runners capable of staying in a competitive race deep into the course, even though only McClain reached the top three.

Ellwood had run 2:22:53 at Boston in April, though she wasn’t listed on a biography page in the New York Marathon media guide. That detail makes the guide an imperfect account of the field, while her Boston time gives useful context for her sixth-place finish. A single result can’t explain a runner’s form or race strategy, but the performances in New York show that several Americans arrived with credentials and produced strong finishes.

McClain earned $85,000 by combining awards for her overall and American finishes. Ellwood received $25,000, while Kelati earned $17,500. McClain works full-time for nonprofits in Arizona, alongside her professional running career. That combination makes her result notable beyond the finishing order: elite marathon training demands sustained work, and she’s balancing it with a job outside the sport.

Her New York result adds to a steady run of major performances. She finished eighth at the 2024 NYC Marathon, eighth in the marathon at the 2025 World Championships, and set a personal best of 2:20:49 at Boston in April. In March, while training for Boston, she also ran 31:15 for 10,000 meters on the track. Those results point to consistency across different competitions and distances, though they don’t make every race predictable. The numbers here are underwhelming only if you look at the podium in isolation; across her recent record, the pattern is stronger.

A second career in running

McClain graduated from Stanford in 2015 and turned professional with Brooks, joining its Beasts track club in Seattle. After disappointing results, she left professional running during the pandemic and returned to Arizona. Training with local men, she ran a downhill marathon in 2022 and finished fourth at Grandma’s Marathon in 2023. The path back wasn’t a straight climb through the usual professional structure. It involved a change in training environment and a return to racing through performances that rebuilt her standing.

Her fourth-place finish at the 2024 U.S. Olympic Marathon Trials marked her return to the national scene. The New York podium is another milestone in a comeback that has made her one of the country’s leading marathoners. Her top-five finish in New York qualifies her for the 2028 Olympic marathon, but she’ll still need to place in the top three at the U.S. trials to make the Los Angeles team. Qualification is a step, not a guarantee of selection; the trials remain the immediate competitive hurdle described by the result.

What the result means next

McClain had already raced in Central Park this year, contesting the women’s Mini 10K in June and the Dash to the Finish Line 5K the day before the marathon. That familiarity, paired with a rehearsed finish and careful cornering, helped turn a difficult early stretch into a career-defining result. If you’re following the American marathon scene, her New York finish is a useful measure of how far she’s come: from stepping away from professional running to competing near the front of a major race.

This is more significant than it looks. A podium place doesn’t resolve the question of whether she can make an Olympic team, but it gives her another high-level result to build on and shows that she can stay composed when the race turns late. And this is the part most people overlook: her story also includes the less visible work of balancing a full-time nonprofit job with elite training. The next test is translating that consistency into a place on the 2028 Olympic team. Still, plenty can happen between a strong marathon and the trials.

Source: Christopher Jones · www.runnersworld.com