Eric Longenhagen on MLB Prospects: Why Performance Needs Context

| 5 min read

Eric Longenhagen’s FanGraphs chat ranges from prospect evaluations to a candy-corn verdict, with one useful thread running through the baseball talk: a bad stat line doesn’t tell you much until you know what sits underneath it. The exchange took place Friday morning, October 30, 2026. Longenhagen opened with a local weather report—Phoenix was already getting rain, with 2–3 inches forecast for the weekend—and said he was looking forward to writing about emo and shoegaze, as he had when he lived in Pennsylvania.

Prospects, roles, and the limits of the numbers

Asked whether Jefferson Rojas’s outlook had shifted over the prior three months, Longenhagen said it hadn’t: he still sees a good everyday infielder, at shortstop or third base, who could rank among the top 20 at his position. He called Rojas a good acquisition and said fans could watch him regularly in LIDOM with Gigantes, where Roldy Brito also often starts.

That’s a fairly steady projection. The more conditional one came in a question about Yankees prospect Kilby: if he keeps hitting as he advances, and isn’t a long-term shortstop, might the team move him quickly given its aging core? Longenhagen said a promotion pace like Lombard’s was reasonable. Sending Kilby to his current level after he had barely played that year was already an aggressive choice, he said, and Kilby had thrived. Longenhagen wouldn’t be surprised if Kilby opened at Hudson Valley.

For the Mets, the concern was whether corner bats Jacob Reimer and Clifford were still close to helping. Longenhagen said Clifford’s limitations had always made a disappointing outcome likely for anyone expecting his peak projection from about two years earlier; a platoon role was the more reasonable ceiling. He remains interested in Reimer, whose injury-affected 2026 line looks worse than his underlying data suggests. But there’s a limit to the upside: Reimer is a physically maxed-out, tightly wound corner player. If he strikes out about a quarter of the time and produces roughly average power, Longenhagen thinks he can contribute, though probably not rank among the top 20 first basemen if that’s his only position.

Position is also the question for Rainiel and Jesús Made. Longenhagen said he’d want to see Rainiel at third before deciding whether the move works. He’s a heavier player, but built somewhat like Max Muncy, who has handled third base well enough and spent time at second. A position change could get Rainiel’s bat into a lineup sooner, since he still has substantial work to do as a catcher. Longenhagen agreed that Made should get a look at third, at least in LIDOM; Pratt is the better defender. He added that Joey Ortiz and David Hamilton shouldn’t block a potential 30-homer third baseman.

Some evaluations were more direct. Longenhagen likes John Peck, who had come seemingly out of nowhere and had attractive underlying numbers, including player comparisons on Savant. Still, he sees Peck as a good utility player rather than a first-division regular. He expects Vance Honeycutt back on the main list next year. Honeycutt’s defense should give him a role, though a roughly 30% strikeout rate makes a consistent two-plus-WAR projection difficult. Longenhagen said Honeycutt had crushed the day before and hit a ball 108 mph to straightaway center field.

For Bonemer, the concern was whether his arm ruled out right field, or whether center field simply offered easier reads. The question cited Longenhagen’s earlier assessment: “Bonemer entered the AFL season as the one of this group I was worried I’d come away feeling more skeptical about because of how much whiffing he did during the regular season. Instead, I think his power is weaponized by sufficient barrel feel. He is likely to be a left field-only defender in the big leagues, but he could have output similar to Teoscar Hernández.” Longenhagen’s explanation was brief: Bonemer isn’t a natural thrower from the outfield.

Seaver King drew a more substantial reassessment. Longenhagen expects Washington to manage his service time and maximize its years of control. He had been very high on King coming out of college, then grew skeptical late in 2025 because King couldn’t pull the ball and looked shaky on defense. After an excellent season, King needs a fresh evaluation for the next list cycle. Longenhagen credited Washington’s new leadership with improving its hitters quickly and is inclined to view King’s year as a real step forward, rather than a product of an unusual minor-league offensive environment.

That same caution applies to younger hitters who disappoint over a full season. Asked how to weigh a poor year from toolsy prospects such as Jansel Luis and Gabriel Rodriguez, Longenhagen said the answer depends on the reasons behind the line: Were they young for the level? Were they hurt? Do the underlying numbers tell a better story than the surface production? Those questions can justify giving a prospect the benefit of the doubt, but they don’t make the disappointing season disappear.

Trade guesses and a quick detour

Asked to predict where Skubal might land, Longenhagen went with the Braves. His reasoning was their future payroll flexibility: he pointed to money coming off the books over the next few years for Acuña, Sale, Profar, Albies, and Suárez. He also wondered aloud about a change-of-scenery deal involving Ketel and Acuña, while noting that one more year of Albies would make the fit less obvious. It was a speculative guess, not a report of active trade discussions.

There were a couple of broader questions, too. Longenhagen expects an agreement before the lockout’s effects on the minor leagues, draft, and amateur baseball are fully settled: the sides may decide to “here’s the deal, let’s play baseball,” then work through draft and international issues in the following weeks. Asked about names from instructs or the bridge league, he pointed out that instructs had ended a couple of weeks earlier and said most of the top players were already familiar. He liked Angeibel Gomez, the Giants infielders, Grindlinger, and Comeau, and suggested readers look at the pieces he wrote during that stretch.

One keeper-league question asked whether swapping Dax Kilby for Grady Emerson was a mistake. Longenhagen called it a likely lateral move, but said he’d need to know much more about the league and roster to give a sound judgment.

And, because this was a chat, the conversation briefly left prospect evaluation behind. Asked about candy corn, Longenhagen said he’d eat it: it wasn’t high on his preference list, but he was curious enough to try it again, especially the pumpkins. Later, as he answered King’s question, he reported that lightning was striking alarmingly close by—“like cartoon sound effect lightning.”

Scouting is still a question of what holds up

The Arizona Fall League can sharpen an evaluation, but it doesn’t turn every intriguing prospect into an impact player. On Atlanta’s Owen Carey and Isaiah Drake, Eric Longenhagen sees two legitimate prospects with fairly modest ceilings. Drake has exceptional speed and a running back’s physicality. His data is interesting: a very high launch angle paired with roughly average contact. But his swing feel looks crude, leaving the main question unresolved: can he hit enough to be more than a specialist? Carey is on time to pull the ball, but looks like a left fielder with a 30 arm. Longenhagen can picture him as a corner platoon bat; how much strength he adds will matter. That same patience applies to Bryce Rainer. Longenhagen doesn’t think his swing needs an immediate offseason overhaul. He expects Rainer may shorten it naturally after struggling and having to adjust. That’s a reasonable bet, though it leaves open how quickly the contact rates from his rookie season might return.

Roles, playing time, and the value of another look

For Chase Harlan, the missing piece is more defensive observation. His eventual position changes how his bat stacks up: league-average wRC+ at third base was 98 this year, compared with 111 at first. A few more looks in the field could therefore change the shape of his projection. The role question is clearer for a couple of other players. Brooks Auger has the build and movement of a starter, but commands the ball more like a reliever. Longenhagen sees a swingman as the likely fit in his organization. Chandler Simpson’s unusual throwing motion, meanwhile, may cap his arm strength around the 20/30 range; Longenhagen expects the team will have to live with it. At catcher, Rafael Flores can still play a major role for Pittsburgh, even if “daily” is the wrong expectation. Longenhagen points out that only a handful of catchers now play every day. He expects Flores to share the workload, perhaps catching 80 games rather than 120, and thinks he can thrive as a hitter in that arrangement. Axel Plaz drew a blunt comparison: Longenhagen likened him to Jorge Alfaro.

Depth can buy a team time

The Mets have enough corner-infield options to wait and see who emerges. Longenhagen puts Baty and Vientos, along with Ronny Mauricio, ahead of Reimer and Clifford. The group is deep enough to absorb some players regressing while others improve; with enough chances in the mix, the Mets may capture the peak years of the best few. He’s similarly reluctant to write off a prospect because injury has cost him a year or two. Yairo Padilla was the example in the question, and Ethan Salas the counterexample: lost playing time alone isn’t grounds to dismiss a young player. For the Cardinals’ outfielders, Longenhagen picked Frias when asked who might produce the highest peak-season WAR among Walker, Baez, Peete, Frias, and Condon. In the Brewers’ return from the Peralta trade, he still expects Sproat to be good, while Jett Williams looks more like a role player. And on the question of whether Zion Rose had passed Burress after his AFL showing, Longenhagen still preferred Burress. He had looked good in instructs, and Longenhagen wished the team had sent him to the AFL instead of Guedez; Burress, he said, is the more explosive athlete in the box. There’s a more speculative kind of upside in Jake Cook, who entered the draft with little hitting experience. Longenhagen clocked him under 3.9 seconds multiple times, speed he compared to Billy Hamilton. Cook has more size than Hamilton and remains relatively green as a hitter. Longenhagen thinks he could become pretty good, and expects him to be fun to watch develop.

The work behind the rankings

The least tidy part of prospect evaluation may be fitting it into a working day. Longenhagen described a trip to Peoria with Laurila: they arrived early because Laurila interviews players before games, then tried to write in a press box where people naturally wanted to socialize. Patrick Reilly was useful to watch for four innings in perfect weather. After that, the pitching deteriorated into a game with roughly 24 combined walks, including three pitchers who took too long to finish an inning. Leaving early felt awkward among the scouts, who might not know he was returning to the press box to work. Longenhagen called this the hardest part of the job in his ten years doing it: matching the depth he can provide—and sees as a differentiator for the site, alongside writing quality—to an audience that wants everything now and pays less attention to lower-ranked prospects, including 40s and players rated 35-plus. That tension also explains why he wants to make a video podcast series about how the prospect lists are built, potentially showing the evaluation process from mechanics through more advanced judgments. Asked what successful clubs such as the Dodgers, Brewers, and Rays might do next that others copy, he named a specific Brewers practice: tailoring bat design to each player’s swing. On the possibility that a looming lockout could affect front-office hiring and player development around spring training and the opening month of the minor-league season, he expected some budget-conscious teams to make fewer additions to their operations staffs, as happened during COVID and the previous lockout. One question in the exchange remains open: whether Elijah Green should try football at Georgia was met with a joke about why he hadn’t started already. The fragment also ends with a question about Derek Curiel—whether he is more likely to stick in center field or develop enough power to become a regular—with no answer included.

Development is a bet on what comes next

The most revealing answer here may be the shortest: Eric Longenhagen sees Cole Carrigg as the toolsiest of a group that also includes Spencer Jones and Victor Mesa. On another player’s physique, he urged patience until February, pointing out that players in their early 20s can add strength quickly once they get into the weight room. That’s a reminder that a prospect’s current build is only a snapshot. Longenhagen put a firmer ceiling on Miguel Hernandez, whom one reader preferred to the Cardinals’ actual draft pick, Condon. His estimate: Hernandez would have been a roughly $700,000 draft signing. The case is mixed. A contact rate below 70% is a worry in Low-A, even with good plate discipline and power for his age. Longenhagen sees potential, but not first-round value. Pitchers, he argued, should generally be developed as starters before their eventual role becomes clear. Some may turn into multi-inning options in the mold of Aaron Ashby; Grant Taylor was another example. That’s a practical point for teams and fantasy managers alike: a pitcher’s best major-league use may emerge only after the organization tests whether he can start. For a dynasty league choice among Johnny King, Kash Mayfield and Bishop Letson, his answer was simply: Kash.

The Arizona Fall League’s difficult read

The Arizona Fall League is a tough environment to interpret. Longenhagen described its pitching as roughly High-A caliber, facing hitters in a California League style run environment. The bullpens, he said, are consistently poor, and many pitchers sent there are returning from injuries that disrupted their regular seasons. That makes performance hard to judge cleanly: the roster itself can reflect health and workload decisions as much as readiness. He also floated a video series built around the prospect lists, an idea he’s considered for a long time. The obstacle is rights clearance. He shoots plenty of his own footage, but broadcast video can better illustrate the point, and securing music and video rights could be difficult. It’s a promising format, though the practical hurdle is real. Longenhagen closed by saying he’d be speaking at First Pitch Arizona during the next scheduled chat slot, so the date or time would change. He asked readers to check the site’s chat schedule and suggested a possible live chat during Fall Stars. Then, as promised, he signed off: “TTFN.” Source
Source: Eric Longenhagen · blogs.fangraphs.com