England’s ODI Defeats Expose Batting Depth and Bowling Role Questions

| 5 min read

England’s latest defeats have turned a promising ODI summer into a harder question: can this side manage a match once its preferred plan breaks down? Two losses from commanding positions in four days suggest that the issue isn’t simply a shortage of talent. It’s how England use the players available, and whether the batting and bowling line-ups have enough answers when pressure shifts.

Sri Lanka chased 430 on Thursday. On Sunday, Pakistan reached 242 after England had reduced them to 154-9. The victories belong to Sri Lanka and Pakistan, whose chases deserve credit. But the manner of England’s losses leaves the team with practical problems to address before its next match in Lahore.

Two different collapses, one recurring concern

The defeats exposed different weaknesses. Against Sri Lanka, England couldn’t take enough wickets through the middle overs, a problem that has dogged the team in one-day cricket for some time. Against Pakistan, Jamie Overton and Liam Dawson did make inroads. England’s failure came at the finish, when Pakistan’s last pair turned a near-certain loss into a successful chase.

That distinction matters. It would be easy to treat the two results as one general failure of nerve, but the remedies aren’t identical. England need to find ways to break partnerships in the middle overs, then finish innings with the lower order under pressure. Sunday showed that reaching nine down doesn’t guarantee a result if the last two batters can score freely and England’s bowlers can’t close the door.

England’s own total made the job more difficult. They were all out for 241, a below-par score on a Lahore pitch that offered no clear excuse for such a modest return. Shadab Khan made 113 not out at No. 8 for Pakistan; England’s No. 10, Gus Atkinson, finished unbeaten on 36. Those contributions underline how much more England needed from their top and middle order.

The weekend match was lost primarily with the bat. Jos Buttler is injured and Jacob Bethell is recovering from injury, leaving England without two players who could have added runs and experience. Their absence also reduced Harry Brook’s options as captain when the fielding innings began to unravel. A senior voice can’t guarantee a better result, but England’s inexperienced group has fewer sources of guidance when a plan stops working.

Curran’s role remains unsettled

Sam Curran is another player whose place and purpose need definition. England wanted his left-arm variety during the 2025 Champions Trophy in Pakistan, when the team lost all three matches. Since returning to white-ball cricket, he has delivered useful contributions, including a decisive final over as England avoided defeat against Nepal at the T20 World Cup in India earlier this year.

Pakistan offered a mixed picture. Curran’s 42 helped England recover from 52-4, and his figures of 0-32 from eight overs look respectable on paper. Yet the details of his spell were less reassuring. In his fifth, sixth and seventh overs, he gave Shadab boundary-scoring opportunities and then conceded a single. He also didn’t put enough pressure on No. 11 Haris Rauf when the chance came.

Three days earlier, Curran had taken 2-103 from nine overs against Sri Lanka, the most expensive ODI figures by an England bowler. Brook kept turning to him as the innings continued, and the result eclipsed Curran’s previous personal worst of 0-98 from 9.5 overs against the West Indies in 2023. His recent groin injury, which kept him out for two months, may help explain some rustiness. It doesn’t settle the question of what England need from him now.

Stuart Broad is among those who argue that Curran is most effective with a clear, prominent role. That’s a useful question for the team to answer. If England expect him to contribute in every phase without giving him a defined job, they risk getting less from his batting and his bowling. If his form with the ball doesn’t improve, his place could come under pressure.

Overton’s recent work in the middle overs adds to that selection debate. He has taken important wickets by bowling a hard length, and could strengthen his case further by offering more with the bat. If England want another specialist seamer in the side as they build towards the 2027 World Cup in Africa, the balance between Overton and Curran may become more difficult to maintain.

Rashid’s absence raises a separate selection question

Adil Rashid has missed the last two matches, with Liam Dawson selected instead. Dawson has performed well in the tri-series, so his selection has a clear cricketing case. Even so, leaving Rashid out twice has prompted questions about whether England are managing his return to full fitness or reconsidering the role of a bowler who has anchored the attack for more than a decade.

His place in the squad for next month’s Australia tour points towards a continuing role. Rashid’s home summer ended early because of a hand injury, and his current absence could reflect a cautious return. But his 2026 ODI numbers are below his recent standard: nine wickets in seven matches, at an average of 36.22 and a strike rate of 37.50. In 2025, he took 30 wickets in 15 games, averaging 23.63 with a strike rate of 24.10. Nasser Hussain said last week that Rashid’s performances had “dropped off”.

England’s choice between Rashid and Dawson is therefore more than a routine change. Dawson’s success makes it harder to select Rashid automatically, while Rashid’s record makes it difficult to regard his absence as a straightforward end to his international role. England will need to judge his fitness and current form alongside the balance of the attack.

A test for a developing side

Brook said the players were “gutted” after both defeats and stressed that the group remained determined to perform for England. He also acknowledged that the team isn’t yet the best version it can be. With an inexperienced line-up and a World Cup in 12 months, he said England have only 20 matches in which to learn and build the communication they need.

That timeframe gives the team room to develop, but it also makes selection and role clarity urgent. Buttler, Bethell and Jofra Archer were unavailable for this run of matches; Archer was rested, while Josh Tongue also missed Sunday’s defeat. Their returns could improve England’s options, but they won’t automatically resolve the questions raised by the last two games.

England’s home ODI series wins over India and Sri Lanka showed what this group can do when its plans hold. The tri-series has shown the other side: a team that has struggled to recover after losing control, first in a chase against Pakistan and then while defending large totals. Coach Brendon McCullum remains in place to work through those problems, with the next opportunity coming against Sri Lanka in Lahore.

That match will offer a useful measure of whether England can turn two painful finishes into changes on the field. The immediate priorities are clear: produce a stronger batting total, give Curran a role that suits his strengths, and settle how Rashid fits alongside Dawson. England don’t need to solve every long-term question at once, but they do need a more convincing response when an opponent pushes them off script.

England face Sri Lanka in Lahore on Thursday. Coverage begins at 7:30am UK and Ireland time on Sky Sports Cricket and Main Event, with the first ball at 8am. Latest Sky Sports deals or stream with no contract through NOW - cancel anytime.

All games live on Sky Sports; all times UK and Ireland.

Source: Robert Rodriguez · www.skysports.com