Tom Brady Praises Aaron Rodgers and Matthew Stafford’s Passing Touch
Tom Brady’s praise for Aaron Rodgers and Matthew Stafford comes down to more than arm strength. He sees two quarterbacks whose throws look unusually smooth and accurate—and whose instincts, in his view, were present long before they reached the NFL. Their highlight reels offer a vivid case for that assessment, from Rodgers’ playoff Hail Marys to Stafford’s no-look passes and a game-winning throw made as a rookie.
Brady’s picks: Rodgers and Stafford
Asked in a recent edition of #AskTom which quarterback throws the prettiest ball in the league, Brady named two: Rodgers and Stafford. He went further, saying their ability to spin the ball ranks with the best he has seen in NFL history. “Both those guys spin the ball as well as anybody that's ever played,” Brady said. “They have silky-smooth deliveries. They're so accurate, and it's just effortless when it comes out of their hands.”
Brady has made a similar case for Rodgers before. In April 2025, when asked which quarterback had the most talented arm in NFL history, he said Rodgers and Dan Marino were the first names that came to mind. Rodgers’ four MVP awards—the second-most in league history—help explain why his arm has long been a point of comparison with the greats.
His current production still gives that reputation some context. At 42, Rodgers has passed for 1,487 yards, 12 touchdowns and five interceptions this season, helping the Pittsburgh Steelers reach a 4-2 start. Stafford, 38, is leading the league in passing yards entering Week 7, with 1,794 for the Los Angeles Rams. He won his first MVP last season at age 37 and has kept producing the throws that drew Brady’s attention.
Natural feel, refined by repetition
Brady’s explanation is less about a single mechanical trait than a quality that develops early and becomes ingrained. He described some players as natural passers from childhood, with organized practice later sharpening what already comes intuitively.
“I think there's really natural passers from the time you're born, and you see that all the way through baseball leagues, and then Pop Warner football,” Brady said. College practice, he added, helps refine that ability. By the time a quarterback reaches the pros, the fundamentals are “pretty hardwired.” Adjustments remain possible, but Brady thinks Rodgers and Stafford arrived in the league with that feel already in place.
That view helps explain why Brady points to their delivery as much as their results. Smooth mechanics can make difficult throws look routine. Rodgers and Stafford have also built distinctive styles of improvisation, turning pressure and tight coverage into some of the most memorable passes of their careers.
Rodgers’ signature: distance and precision
Rodgers’ most famous long throw may be his 61-yard Hail Mary against the Detroit Lions in 2015. The play, later known as the “Miracle in Motown,” began with Rodgers scrambling behind the line. He launched the ball from the Packers’ 35-yard line, and Richard Rodgers caught it in the end zone for the winning score. Its distance and finish have kept it in the conversation over the best Hail Marys in NFL history.
That season brought another pair of extraordinary throws in Green Bay’s playoff loss to the Arizona Cardinals. On fourth-and-20, Rodgers found Jeff Janis with a completion that traveled nearly 60 yards through the air, moving the Packers from deep in their own territory into Arizona’s side of the field. A few plays later, he avoided the pass rush and connected with Janis on a Hail Mary touchdown, again sending the ball nearly 60 air yards.
One season later, Rodgers produced a different kind of highlight against the Dallas Cowboys. Scrambling to his left in a divisional playoff game, he squeezed a 36-yard pass past a defender and into Jared Cook’s hands near the sideline. Cook kept himself in bounds, and the completion helped set up Green Bay’s game-winning field goal. The throw demanded precision as much as power: Rodgers had to locate Cook while moving, and Cook had to control his position at the boundary.
Rodgers also delivered on football’s biggest stage. In the Packers’ Super Bowl XLV win over the Pittsburgh Steelers, he threw a 21-yard touchdown to Greg Jennings between safeties Ryan Clark and Troy Polamalu. Clark dived but couldn’t reach the ball; Polamalu arrived too late to disrupt it. The pass was a display of placement into a narrow window, the same kind of accuracy Brady singled out.
Stafford’s no-look throws—and a rookie’s resolve
Stafford’s signature moments often involve deception. In the closing minutes of Super Bowl LVI, with the Rams needing a touchdown, he looked toward the sideline and threw over the middle to Cooper Kupp for a 22-yard gain. The glance helped sell the defense on one target while the ball went to another. The Rams went on to score the touchdown they needed.
Stafford has continued to use the same kind of misdirection. Last season, he looked toward the flat before throwing a touchdown to Puka Nacua on a slant against the Seattle Seahawks. The appeal of a no-look pass isn’t just visual flair: it can make a defender hesitate or send their attention away from the receiver’s actual route.
Yet one of Stafford’s most striking throws came much earlier, during his rookie season with the Detroit Lions in 2009. He separated his non-throwing shoulder late in a game against the Cleveland Browns. A pass-interference penalty gave Detroit the ball at the 1-yard line, and Stafford stayed on the field. He threw a tight spiral to Brandon Pettigrew for the touchdown that won the game.
That play captures another side of the talent Brady described: accuracy under pressure, with little time to reset. Stafford’s later no-look passes show how he can manipulate defenders; the rookie touchdown showed his willingness to make a precise throw while hurt in a decisive moment.
The hardest throw for Brady
Brady was also asked to compare a go route down the sideline with a pass over the middle. He said the deep post was tougher for him. A go route usually gave him one primary defender to account for and a receiver running straight downfield, making the receiver’s speed easier to judge. Brady could then shape the ball’s arc and drop it into the receiver’s path.
A post route, by comparison, sends the receiver across the field as well as down it. Brady said that movement was harder to read and could bring both a safety and a cornerback into the play, creating what he called a “two-on-one ball.” He believes he threw more touchdown passes on go routes than on posts during his career.
There isn’t a single career total in the source data that settles how Brady performed on post routes. Pro Football Focus data does point to a difference in his deep passing: in 10 of his final 16 seasons, he recorded more touchdowns and a higher passer rating on throws of 20-plus yards outside the numbers than on throws of the same distance between the numbers.
Brady’s comments connect the mechanics, instincts and decisions behind a memorable throw. Rodgers’ long-range improvisation and Stafford’s deception look different on film, but both reflect the accuracy and feel Brady says are hard to teach. Their continued production gives the comparison a present-day edge, while their signature throws show why their passing styles remain easy to recognize.