Fielding Bible Awards: Defensive Standouts in the Outfield, at Pitcher and Around the Diamond

| 5 min read
Nathan Ray Seebeck, David Banks, Mike Watters-Imagn Images

The most revealing part of a defensive awards ballot is often where the numbers and the eye test disagree. For this half of my 2026 Fielding Bible Awards vote, that tension shows up across the outfield, at pitcher, and among players who moved around the diamond. The winners have now been announced; an asterisk marks each winner below. The awards were announced at 3 PM ET the day after my first installment, which covered the infield.

My infield ballot explains the method in more detail. In brief, I combined DRS, FRV, and DRP, weighting the three public defensive metrics according to their reliability and consistency. That produced a starting order for each position. I then checked it against video, player-specific analysis, and the considerable amount of baseball I watched this season. Big statistical gaps carried weight; close decisions came down largely to judgment. The metrics help organize the evidence, but they don’t make every call for you.

Left field

1. Cody Bellinger*
2. Chandler Simpson
3. Jackson Chourio
4. Ian Happ
5. Wyatt Langford

Bellinger’s move into a mostly full-time left field role made this the easiest first-place decision on my outfield ballot. He spent last year moving around the outfield; this season, he settled largely into left and showed why he belongs among the sport’s best defenders. His anticipation and routes are excellent, he has enough speed, and his arm can change a runner’s plans. With Steven Kwan now in center, Bellinger stood apart at a position that offered a thinner field of contenders. I didn’t have a serious alternative for the top spot.

Without Bellinger, Simpson and Chourio would have made the top of this ballot a real debate. They get their defensive value in different ways, but both belong near the top. Simpson’s arm is among the weakest in the game; his range makes up for a lot. The fastest player in baseball already had the raw speed to cover ground, but last season his slow reactions often kept that speed from paying off. This year, only Jacob Young reacted faster among outfielders. Simpson’s routes can be inefficient, but he accelerates so quickly that he still gets to balls other players can’t reach. He sometimes has to slow himself down to avoid overrunning a catch. Tampa Bay kept him out of center this season; a move there in a future year would make sense, and his range could look even more valuable.

Chourio isn’t as fast as Simpson, but he’s a complete five-tool player with an arm that trails Bellinger’s only slightly. He piled up outfield assists without a single throwing error. Runners had good reason to think twice before taking an extra base against Milwaukee, and Chourio was a major part of that deterrent. I ranked Simpson second, but the gap between them is small enough that my order could change on another day. Both are exceptional defenders.

Happ keeps landing on my ballot, though he’s never been close to the top. The three players ahead of him look more like center fielders stationed in left; Happ is a more traditional fit. He lacks standout speed and arm strength, but he gets moving quickly and knows exactly how to use what he has. Statcast ranks his arm strength 199th, yet credits his arm with the sixth-highest run value. The explanation is practical: Happ reaches the ball quickly and throws accurately, so runners are reluctant to test him.

Langford rounds out the five. His jumps have improved with experience, and he was particularly effective moving forward to make diving and sliding catches. His arm had a weaker season, but that matters less in left than it would elsewhere. It’s a good defensive turnaround for a player who arrived with questions about his glove.

Center field

1. Pete Crow-Armstrong
2. Ceddanne Rafaela*
3. Andy Pages
4. Michael Harris II
5. Evan Carter

Crow-Armstrong and Rafaela are the two best defenders in baseball, by my read, and the difficulty is that they play the same position. I watched both constantly this year, often because they’re simply fun to watch. Crow-Armstrong led my blended metric ranking by a comfortable margin, and he’d still have been my choice without that lead. This catch was my favorite of his season, though there’s no shortage of candidates. He combines remarkable speed and the best jumps in the game with a strong arm. I’m skeptical of FRV’s estimate that he was ten runs better than Rafaela in center, but I do think Crow-Armstrong was the best center fielder this year.

Rafaela won this award last year after getting my first-place vote, and his 2026 season was just as impressive. He covers everything and follows it with throws that can stop runners in their tracks. The reason Crow-Armstrong came out ahead is partly visible in the difficult chances: Statcast classified 79 of Crow-Armstrong’s plays as less than 90% likely to be made, and he converted 65. Rafaela had 74 such opportunities and turned 47 into outs. They’re both spectacular; I may even enjoy watching Rafaela more. But Crow-Armstrong’s season made the stronger case.

Pages and Harris have already established themselves as standout defenders. Pages made a memorable catch in last year’s World Series; Harris is no newcomer to this group either. Carter edged out several credible alternatives: Cedric Mullins, Young, Tristan Peters, and Jackson Merrill. His arm is a little short of theirs, but his range stood out. He repeatedly covered the gaps and helped compensate for shaky defense in right field.

Right field

1. Wilyer Abreu*
2. Corbin Carroll
3. Carson Benge
4. Seiya Suzuki
5. Victor Mesa Jr.

Abreu and Carroll finished second and third behind Fernando Tatis Jr. on my ballot last year. Both stayed strong this season, while Tatis had a down year and spent 400 innings at second base. Abreu offers the classic right fielder’s package: good jumps, solid top speed, and one of baseball’s strongest arms. He also handles Fenway’s wide right-field territory well. Several defensive systems seem to give Boston right field an extra boost; I can’t see their underlying calculations, but the pattern looks like systematic over-credit. Still, playing a difficult home park well counts. Even after allowing for that possible skew, Abreu’s ability to keep runners from advancing put him ahead of Carroll.

Carroll’s arm is below average, but that’s about the only clear weakness in his defense. He turns elite speed into range by exploding at contact and building to full speed immediately. His routes aren’t textbook, yet they work: he curves toward the ball at speed, producing both spectacular catches and routine-looking outs that become possible because he read the play early. If this ballot were for left field, I’d favor Carroll. In right, runners challenge his arm more often, and Abreu’s strength in that area was hard to overlook.

Benge made an immediate impression as a rookie. His arm already looks right for an elite right fielder, while his speed and instincts give him the tools to handle center. A little more experience should sharpen the edges; he could win this award multiple times. Ranking him above Suzuki took some thought, especially because Suzuki’s defensive metrics were better across the board. But the gap was narrow, and I couldn’t reconcile those numbers with what I saw. Suzuki isn’t a poor fielder, and he recorded plenty of assists, but outside his arm value he looked closer to average. Benge struck me as a more complete version of a similar skill set.

Mesa’s regular-season defense was eye-catching even before he made headlines in the playoffs. He played just over 500 innings, yet his per-inning numbers put him far ahead of other right fielders. I hesitated to rank him first on such a limited sample; I was more comfortable doing that for Matt Chapman at third base after a strong, similarly limited run. I have less confidence that the models have Mesa fully right, since he doesn’t have years of evidence to confirm the result. Even so, the eye test supports the numbers: his arm is plainly elite, and leaving him off because he didn’t reach the majors until partway through the season would have been a mistake.

Pitcher

1. Tanner Bibee*
2. Shota Imanaga
3. Michael McGreevy
4. Brent Suter
5. Seth Lugo

This is the ballot I trust least. Pitchers field few innings and even fewer chances, so there’s not much to watch or measure. I leaned heavily on Statcast’s data about controlling the running game. Preventing runners from advancing won’t produce many highlight clips, but pitchers rarely get to show off their fielding in the first place. It seemed like the clearest skill to reward. I also considered their work on balls in play; every pitcher listed here was difficult to run on.

Bibee, Imanaga, and McGreevy tied for the best record at preventing advances. Bibee had the strongest DRS and looked best on the mound, so I used those as the tiebreaker. Suter and Lugo both excelled at holding runners and graded well by DRS in other fielding areas. That’s the basis for these five rankings. There isn’t a more elaborate argument behind them.

Multi-position defender

1. Nasim Nuñez
2. Zach McKinstry*
3. Joey Ortiz
4. José Caballero
5. Steven Kwan

This category is hard to rank because several players who could have earned votes at one position spent the year moving around. Any ordering of these five would be defensible: each showed elite defense at a valuable spot. I gave Nuñez the top vote after considerable hesitation. He began the year as Washington’s everyday second baseman, then shifted to shortstop when the Nationals decided CJ Abrams wasn’t a long-term fit there. Nuñez handled the move with sure hands, good range, and a stronger arm than his size suggests. His 493 plate appearances came with a .535 OPS, yet Washington kept him on the field because his glove was that valuable.

Ortiz and Caballero built similar cases, playing excellent defense on the left side of the infield while switching between shortstop and third. Caballero also saw some time in the outfield, but his work there didn’t earn extra credit from me. Either could contend for a Fielding Bible Award with a full season at third; I wouldn’t put either, or Nuñez, first at shortstop. Nuñez played the most defensive innings while posting similar per-inning results, which settled the order for me. Over the longer term, I think Ortiz may be the best defender of the three.

My runner-up was McKinstry. He’s a strong candidate to win the award after playing 500 infield innings and 500 outfield innings with above-average defense in both. His powerful arm made him a threat in right, and he also did the job at second and shortstop, giving Detroit options as its lineup changed. Better confidence in his outfield range might have pushed him to first. His arm wasn’t the question; the range was.

Kwan’s path to this ballot is unusual: he played well enough in left to move to center, which may have cost him a stronger case as a multi-position defender. He was the league’s best multi-position outfielder in my view, but his overall case didn’t quite match the top four. His skill set also looks different from theirs, and that earns him the fifth spot.

Defensive Player of the Year

1. Pete Crow-Armstrong*
2. Ceddanne Rafaela
3. Dillon Dingler

Crow-Armstrong and Rafaela were the two defenders who stood above the field for me this season. Comparing infielders with outfielders is difficult, and catchers make the exercise harder still. But I believe these two gave their teams more defensive value than anyone else on the ballot. The volume of highlights was part of the case, too: I saw more memorable plays from them than from the rest of the group combined. They were extraordinary to watch, and Crow-Armstrong gets my award.

Dingler earned the final place on my ballot. He was the best defender at the game’s most important defensive position, and he’s the kind of complete, polished catcher I value. In a less extraordinary year for outfield defense, I could have put him first. But Crow-Armstrong and Rafaela set such a high bar that I had Dingler firmly in third. I also weighed Brice Turang and Masyn Winn, my leading choices at the other two up-the-middle spots. Dingler edged them out.

Defensive Team of the Year
1. Tampa Bay Rays
2. Chicago Cubs*
3. Los Angeles Dodgers

The Rays made defense feel inevitable

This award is still hard to define. Should it reward a roster packed with strong defenders, a coaching staff that puts them in the right places, or the chemistry that lets the whole group move as one? I don’t know how to measure that last part cleanly. So I combined the advanced metrics with each team’s record of turning balls in play into outs, then added my own judgment from watching them.

That approach put Tampa Bay first. Four plus outfielders rotated through the group, and opposing fly balls seemed to find a glove with startling regularity. The Rays also shared catcher duties among three backstops I rate highly. Taylor Walls was outstanding at shortstop, while Junior Caminero deserves credit for a major defensive step forward at third. Tampa Bay cycled through plenty of players, yet finished with baseball’s lowest BABIP by a wide margin. Watching them, I kept expecting a dangerous inning to disappear after one more play.

Great metrics, different feel

The Cubs topped the advanced defensive measures and look likely to collect plenty of individual awards. I put their players on my ballot at six positions, including Defensive Player of the Year. Nico Hoerner and Dansby Swanson joined Crow-Armstrong in giving Chicago a formidable defensive core, with Alex Bregman adding Gold Glove-caliber play at third. Still, catcher and first base looked like weak spots. The Cubs’ defense felt less like a complete unit than a showcase for Crow-Armstrong’s brilliance. That’s a close call, but it left Tampa Bay just ahead.

The Dodgers make a different case. They had few obvious stars on defense and probably won’t claim a Fielding Bible Award, yet they turned balls in play into outs more effectively than every team but one. Their roster has its share of older players and questionable gloves, assembled in part to fit more productive bats into the lineup. Shohei Ohtani also limits their access to the DH spot, which complicates the defensive picture even as it signals an enviable roster problem. Somehow, the group works. If this award is meant to recognize team defense, the Dodgers belong near the top: their results are remarkable given the players they put on the field.

Source

Source: Ben Clemens · blogs.fangraphs.com