Luke Holman’s AFL Return Highlights the Reds Prospect’s Pitch Mix and Health

Luke Holman’s first extended stretch of healthy pitching is beginning to answer the most useful question about the Reds prospect: what can his repertoire do when he can build innings? So far in the Arizona Fall League, the 23-year-old right-hander has given up one run across nine innings in three starts for the Peoria Desert Dogs. He has struck out 15, allowed four hits and issued one walk.
His latest outing offered a strong snapshot. Against a Scottsdale Scorpions lineup featuring prospects Zyhir Hope, Bryce Rainer and Nathan Flewelling, Holman worked four scoreless innings on 52 pitches. The performance drew praise from FanGraphs lead prospect analyst Eric Longenhagen, who sees a possible back-end starter if Holman can sustain his stuff over a longer outing.
A promising start after a disrupted path
Cincinnati selected Holman 71st overall in 2024 out of Louisiana State University, where his rotation included Kade Anderson and Gage Jump. His professional start was brief: two effective appearances in April 2025 ended when an elbow injury led to Tommy John surgery, sidelining him for the rest of the season. A groin issue then limited him to four Arizona Complex League appearances this past season.
“The Reds wanted me to be 100% healthy, then go at it — basically be ready for the Fall League,” Holman said. “It wasn’t the arm. My arm actually feels as good as it’s ever felt.”
That distinction matters. Holman says his fastball’s velocity floor has risen since surgery, while his curveball has returned to its previous form. The Fall League is giving him a chance to test those impressions in competition and begin rebuilding the workload he has lacked.
The curveball sets the terms
Longenhagen clocked Holman’s glove-side fastball command at 92–94 mph and described his curveball, at 78–82 mph, as a plus offering. Holman also uses a mid-80s cutter-slider and a splitter, giving him ways to work against hitters from both sides. Longenhagen’s next questions are how Holman handles a lineup for a second and third time, and whether his arm strength holds as he stretches toward six innings.
The curve is the pitch that most shapes Holman’s approach. Longenhagen previously described it as a high-arcing offering that appears headed beyond the plate before bending into the strike zone. Holman has thrown it since childhood, and says the ride on his fastball helps him create separation between the two pitches.
He can use the curve to steal a strike when hitters take it as it starts high, then change its location later in the count. “Getting it in there, showing that I can land it for strike, kind of lets me [then] do whatever I want with it,” Holman said. “I can bounce it, or throw it wherever.” To get a swing and miss, he tries to make the pitch look hittable before its depth takes it below the barrel.
Building a complete mix
Holman doesn’t yet consider every pitch equally reliable. His slider, which he says plays more like a gyro slider than a sweeper, was a regular part of his college mix but has been inconsistent since Tommy John surgery. He expects it to improve with more innings. The splitter has given him a useful option moving away from left-handed hitters, particularly after he struggled to develop a changeup.
“I threw three splitters today,” he said after one outing. “It will knuckle a little bit here and there, but it’s a true splitter and has been pretty nasty for me.”
Holman is currently ranked 17th in the Cincinnati system with a 40 FV. Longenhagen’s projection of a potential No. 4 or No. 5 starter reflects both the appeal of the curveball and the work still ahead. Holman wants to command all four pitches for strikes; the immediate task is to keep building innings and see whether his full mix returns as his workload grows.